New Albany Coffee

16 specialty shops · curated by Crema

Drink
Vibe
Food
More
Kolkin Coffee in New Albany
4.8(508)

Kolkin Coffee

2736 Charlestown Rd #5

Craft espressoPour overMatcha & teaSlow sit

Tucked in New Albany, this espresso-focused spot has earned serious loyalty with consistently excellent coffee and a…

Cup of Joy in New Albany
4.8(280)

Cup of Joy

2507 Bank St

Slow sitFull breakfastFamily friendlyMeetings

Cup of Joy runs as a nonprofit through a local church ministry, which means your coffee money actually goes somewhere…

Vic's Cafe in New Albany
4.5(597)

Vic's Cafe

1839 E Market St

Slow sitFull breakfastMeetingsLight food

Vic's is beloved for homemade comfort food—think slow-cooked chicken and dumplings, tender roast beef, and mashed…

Cultivated Table and Sip House in New Albany
4.4(88)

Cultivated Table and Sip House

133 E Market St

Signature drinksSlow sitFull breakfastPastries

This spot pulls off the farm-to-table angle better with food than with coffee—the biscuits and locally sourced…

Out of the Blue - Coffee and Ice cream in New Albany
5.0(7)

Out of the Blue - Coffee and Ice cream

112 W Main St

Signature drinksCold brewSlow sitOutdoor seating

They do both coffee and ice cream well, with a real emphasis on the ice cream side—reviewers rave about generous…

4.8(333)

Village House Coffee

8251 IN-64

Signature drinksSlow sitOutdoor seatingFull breakfast

The baristas here genuinely remember regulars' orders and customizations, which speaks to a team that actually…

4.7(651)

Coffee Crossing

8105 County Rd 311

Craft espressoOutdoor seatingFull breakfastPastries

Coffee Crossing pulls off that rare balance of serious espresso work and genuinely welcoming neighborhood…

4.8(132)

My Cup Runneth Over Coffee & Charcuterie Cafe

105 Market St

Craft espressoSignature drinksSlow sitOutdoor seating

The espresso here is genuinely impressive—customers keep coming back specifically for drinks like the Pride and…

5.0(32)

Once Upon A Bean

100 W Jefferson St

Craft espressoSignature drinksSlow sitFull breakfast

The owners have genuinely crafted something special here—reviewers who've driven from neighboring towns rave about…

4.5(349)

Parlor Doughnuts

3531 Grant Line Rd

Full breakfastPastriesFamily friendlyParking

Their doughnuts are laminated and croissant-like rather than traditional cake or yeast varieties, and they're glazed to…

4.8(25)

Palmyra Bean & Cream Café

14285 Greene St NE

Slow sitFull breakfastPastriesFamily friendly

This café is clearly built around exceptional ice cream and a genuinely warm atmosphere—the reviews consistently rave…

4.6(46)

Starlight Coffee Co.

101 Lafollette Station Dr

Signature drinksCold brewLaptop friendlyOutdoor seating

Starlight's baristas aren't just making drinks—they're creating them, from their signature Grandma's House Latte to…

4.4(342)

Heine Brothers Coffee - State Street

414 W Daisy Ln

Craft espressoSignature drinksSlow sitOutdoor seating

This spot has built genuine loyalty with regulars who praise the lively atmosphere and solid espresso drinks, though…

5.0(4)

L's Cafe

506 Pearl St

Slow sitFull breakfastPastriesMeetings

L's Cafe has built genuine warmth with a small but devoted crowd who keep coming back for the at-home vibe and notably…

4.2(714)

Sleepy Rooster Morning Kitchen

2204 State St

Slow sitOutdoor seatingFull breakfastPastries

Sleepy Rooster leans hard into comfort-food breakfast—think generous biscuits and gravy, solid hash browns, and omelets…

University Grounds Coffee Shop

4201 Grant Line Rd

University Grounds is an independent coffee shop in New Albany with no reviews yet to indicate what sets it apart. If…

Get maps, trip planning & AI search in the app

Download Crema for iOS