Duke's Tavern
Duke's Tavern — photo 2
Duke's Tavern — photo 3
Duke's Tavern — photo 4
Duke's Tavern — photo 5

Duke's Tavern

5841 Transit Rd E, Amherst, NY

★★★★★4.5(548 Google reviews)

Crema's Take

Duke's Tavern strikes that rare balance between polished cocktail bar and neighborhood gathering spot, where you can settle in for creative drinks like their smoked guitar (rye and cognac) alongside genuinely excellent comfort food—their beer-battered fish fry is the stuff of local legend. The vibe is warm and unhurried, perfect for lingering over dinner with friends or catching live music on Saturday nights, all served by staff who actually make you feel welcomed rather than rushed.

What to expect

Light foodSpecialty drinksSlow sitMeetingsSignature drinksFamily friendlyLate nightsTraditional drinks

Google Reviews

Robert Hausrath
★★★★★2 months ago

We made reservations at Duke’s Tavern this evening so we could try their fish fry that I had heard so much about… What a phenomenal experience! I enjoyed their beer battered haddock fish fry which is typically accompanied by fries (wedge style) and coleslaw, however, our server, Matthew, welcomed the option to sub out anything off of the sides menu if we wanted. I elected to go for the Mac and cheese in exchange for the coleslaw. Everything was delicious! My wife chose the lemon pepper broiled fish and thought it was very tasty/. Hers was served with fries and roasted brussels sprouts. Servings are plentiful at Duke’s and you will most likely be taking some home for lunch. The bar at Duke’s is outstanding. A very wide selection of spirits and beers can be found at the bar. Mike, the bartender, made me a Basil Hayden smoked old fashioned that was amazing and delicious! As good as the food and drinks were, the star of the show tonight was our served, Matthew. He was knowledgeable, attentive, friendly, and helpful. Very polite and well spoken. It was clear that Matthew puts effort into making sure that his guests not only enjoy their meal, but that they enjoy the full experience. Thank you! Well done! We will be back soon!

Linda Delello
★★★★★2 months ago

We had never been to Duke's Tavern before, and had purchased a Clipp coupon, so we thought we'd give it a try as we were looking for a local establishment that we might, if satisfied by service, food, and atmosphere, might visit frequently. Before we ordered, we informed the waiter that we had a Clipp coupon and were told that it would be accepted. We ordered drinks and meals which were tasty but not mind-blowing. When we asked for the check, the waiter informed us AT THAT TIME that, unfortunately, the manager would NOT accept the coupon due to it being a holiday. I need to add at this point that there is NOTHING on the coupon that reads that holidays are excluded; in fact, no dates or events of any sort are excluded. The waiter remarked that we could use it "next time." There will not be a next time at Duke's for us.

Ridge C
★★★★★3 months ago

Stopped for dinner with friends and really enjoyed the experience. I had the salmon and it was outstanding. Others had the pork chops and really enjoyed them. Saturday nights they had live music and they were great also. Great service and food, we will return. Oh and the owner was in sure interacting, great guy!

Anne Cavaretta
★★★★★9 months ago

Duke’s Tavern is a great place to dine. The food is consistently very good and the atmosphere is a mix of cosmopolitan and casual. Our server Wednesday was Matt. He was great! It was the type of service I’d expect at a high-end restaurant but Duke’s is reasonably priced. Matt was attentive, very well versed on the menu and quick. He picks up on details (like a surprise birthday candle in my husband’s desert). It’s the little things that added up to a great experience. Thanks Matt!

Ann Gramma
★★★★11 months ago

We were 4 ladies out for happy hour and dinner. The drinks were all great, I had the smoked guitar (rye and cognac) delicious! The Asian salad wasn’t great, we sent that back, the salad was nice it was the dressing that needs some work, the other meals were all excellent!! We sat on the patio, I would like to see more flowers hanging or around out there but just so you don’t feel like you’re sitting in a parking lot. I have attached some pics. I would go back and in fact I plan to take my husband! I would recommend dining here!

Crema Reviews

No Crema reviews yet

Been here? Be the first to leave a review in the app.

Write a review on iOS