Crema's Take
“Lorelei Bittner's is where Lake Geneva's community celebrates life's milestones—the staff knows regulars by name and treats every custom cake order like it matters, which it does. The cream puffs and pastries are genuinely excellent, though if you're after espresso drinks rather than traditional coffee, you might be disappointed. It's a genuine neighborhood gathering spot that rewards a slow sit with pastries and warm service, even if you stumble in by accident from the gas station next door.”
What to expect
Classic coffee drinks done right. A slow-sit spot, good for meetings. Pastries on the menu. Family friendly.
Google Reviews
See all on Google →This review is long overdue. Amy and her team have been the key to creating our core memories over the years as we all gather around the cake to celebrate our special occasions. Any ideas I throw out there she is willing to accommodate and goes above and beyond my…
They have med a few cakes for me in the past few years the women there is extremely nice an always does an overly amazing job the cakes turn out great an they are loved by the people they are for
Cake decorating was phenomenal! Truly impressive! Wish I could say the same for flavor. The funfetti cake was dry and mediocre. I asked and paid for both cream cheese filling and frosting but the frosting was just buttercream. For a $110 cake I expected more. So that’s…
In town for a concert. Decided to check out the local bakery. Service was fantastic. Woman behind the counter talked me through my decision making process. She was kind, patient and talkative. 5 stars Atmosphere: kind of a strip mall mext to a gas station. Clean inside and…
We didn’t realize there was a bakery in the strip when we stopped in. We were actually there for the gas station next door. I’m glad we decided to check it out! We got a cream puff. Really good! My husband and I shared it and we were both happy. I got a Pineapple Upside Down…
Crema Reviews
You might also like
Inspired
★ 4.8 (544)
The staff here genuinely treats every order like it matters—locals consistently…
Cafezinho at Main Street Cafe
★ 4.7 (285)
Their signature Canelinha—a cinnamon-forward Brazilian-inspired drink—has…
Main Street Country Store
★ 4.7 (250)
This charming country store hybrid pulls off the rare trick of serving…
Madrez Cafe Elkhorn
★ 4.8 (110)
Madrez Cafe turns breakfast and lunch into something genuinely unexpected—think…