Broad Street Coffee Company
5635 Broad St, Greendale, WI
Crema's Take
“Broad Street Coffee Company is a charming neighborhood gathering spot in Greendale where the staff genuinely remembers you and the atmosphere practically invites you to linger with friends over a second cup. Their specialty drinks like the Celtic Caramel Latte showcase real creativity, though they're still working out the details—their signature espresso drinks sometimes skew milky, and regulars suggest they'd benefit from smaller cups for proper cappuccinos. If you can catch them on a good day with the right barista, you'll find yourself back here again and again, especially if you're an oat milk devotee who wants to double-check your order.”
What to expect
Google Reviews
Glad they had coconut milk but my cappuccino was a latte! Very milky, he gave me an extra shot when I went up to mention it🤗: they need some smaller cups for cappuccinos! (Only 1cup size) They had a couple GF scones too👍
The staff is so friendly and wonderful. It’s a nice cute little spot with good coffee and food options. I had the Celtic Caramel Latter and it was sooooo good. Highly recommend
I love this coffee shop!!! Unfortunately I’ve had several bad experiences with a barista named Allan. I was once served whole milk after asking for oat milk by Allan. After being sick for an afternoon, I went back the next day. When I explained the error, he simply shrugged his shoulders and said, “ Well it was loud in here and the two milks sound a lot alike!!”. Last Saturday, he argued with me over the price of the drink I ordered. This man has no sense of customer service. If I walk in there, and he is working, I will be going to one of the other coffee shops in the village!!
We came from San Diego to visit this cute town and this coffee shop is our morning stable. It is great located next to the 4th of July parade - an iced coffee is kinda essential to watch parade in this warm summer day. I got their seasonal special - it’s a dark chocolate pecan drink, I asked for less sweet, decaf and almond milk. My husband had a double espresso. Both of us enjoyed our drinks, and the barista is professional and friendly. I think my coffee is better than the taste of almost coffee shops in San Diego, I loved it. We also tried their breakfast items, I had a ham and cheese crepe and my husband had a breakfast sandwich, the size is huge and the price is reasonable. Also they are delicious! I’m impressed!
Been here several times. Met a friend for a cup of coffee, and coversation. Very attentive Barista who made an excellent London Fog Latte. Many other tables with small groups, doing the same. Checked out the pastries, but nothing really inspired me. Only wish they had a bit more room for leisurely seating.