Crema's Take
“Gotham Cafe thrives on its role as a genuine neighborhood gathering spot where the espresso is solid but secondary to the warm, family-run atmosphere that keeps regulars coming back for years. The bagels and pastries arrive quickly and unpretentiously, making this the kind of place where locals linger over breakfast rather than rush through their coffee, and where the staff actually remembers who you are. It's not chasing perfection in any single category—instead it excels at being the reliable, bustling cafe where half the room seems to know each other.”
What to expect
Classic coffee drinks done right. A slow-sit spot, good for meetings. Full breakfast, pastries, and light food on the menu. Family friendly.
Google Reviews
See all on Google →A great local place. Not exceptional espresso but pretty decent and the place is bustling with a warm atmosphere. Staff great and family run. A really good place to meet up as it's big enough to always have a chair available
For years I’ve gone to this cafe and ordered teas and baked goods. Sometimes I have to use the restroom after a long commute. I often use the restroom first before ordering because I really have to go or don’t want to take my food and tea in there. So today I decided to use the…
Never going here again. I ordered a Chai Tea Latte and after asking of it was sweet they said it just had vanilla powder. It was not good. It didnt taste like Chai, just vanilla sweet milk. Kinda like a vanilla protein shake but hot. I respectfully and nicely went up to ask the…
I was craving a bagel and while walking to the post office I saw the place and entered. I Ordered a toasted bagel and it was served in record time, I sat and the bagel came Noticed the bagel was not toasted and went to the cashier to let her know and I got the same bagel with…
I stopped in today after having lunch at a nearby restaurant. I was also here a couple of weeks ago and had a panini and it was delicious. Today I just wanted an Americano coffee. Very nicely brewed. Fairly crowded today so I had to sit very close to other people which I do…
Crema Reviews
You might also like
Sunshine Cafe
★ 4.9 (615)
Maria's unwavering commitment to homemade everything—from the bread to the…
Duaa’s Cafe
★ 4.8 (201)
Duaa's is where you go for creative, Instagram-worthy drinks like strawberry…
Mottley Kitchen
★ 4.7 (720)
Mottley Kitchen is a spacious south Bronx gem that takes its food as seriously…
The Station Café
★ 4.8 (175)
The Station pulls off the rare feat of being both a serious espresso…