Brooklyn Hero Shop

I ordered a tuna sandwich expecting something freshly prepared and thoughtfully assembled, but what I received was genuinely disappointing. It appeared to be plain tuna scooped straight from the can and dropped onto the bread without any seasoning, mixing, or basic preparation. There was no mayo, no seasoning, no texture—just dry, flavorless fish. To make matters worse, it was served on the wrong bread, despite my order being clear. Super annoying and a complete waste considering this cost $18.

Came here for the first time to try one of their signature sandwiches: Cold Italian on Hero, and it did deliver. A very delicious Italian sandwich. Service was fast and friendly and the atmosphere chilled. I will definitely comeback here again to try other of their sandwiches.

Honestly was expecting more because their prices are high. I got this fried shrimp sandwich. It was very mediocre, it lacked of flavor, the bread was so dry. It was very expensive for what it is. The service was good! The workers were nice at least.

What a lovely spot! I had the Cold Italian sandwich and it was scrumptious, and if I lived in the neighborhood I would absolutely be there all the time to stock up on pickles and olives and other charcuterie staples. And the sidewalk tables are perfect for people (and dog!) watching

The vibe at Brooklyn Hero Shop is just as good as their sandwiches. I got a Reuben that was out of this world, and my wife raved about the Nashville hot chicken. The staff was so friendly and genuine, making the whole experience really enjoyable. It's clear they care about their customers and their food. If you're looking for a delicious lunch and a welcoming atmosphere, this is your spot.