Penny's Coffee Shop
916 Main St, Buffalo, NY
Crema's Take
“Penny's Coffee Shop has earned a loyal following in Buffalo with its balanced approach to both traditional and creative specialty drinks, making it a reliable spot whether you're after a straightforward espresso or something more adventurous like their matcha offerings. The shop distinguishes itself by pairing quality coffee with a solid food program that spans from light bites to full breakfasts and fresh pastries, creating the kind of neighborhood gathering place where you can settle in for a meal, not just a quick caffeine fix. With a 4.3-star rating across hundreds of reviews, it's clearly struck a chord with locals who appreciate its unpretentious warmth and consistency.”
What to expect
Strong matcha and tea selection. Full breakfast, pastries, and light food on the menu.
Google Reviews
We had such a fun time here at this casual cafe. The food is different and delicious and the drinks were exactly right with the meal. Cozy and relaxed atmosphere.
What a gift to have Penny's downtown- perfect for a lengthy work meeting, a solo cup of coffee, or people watching (all manner of kids are in here). Their lattes (and specials) are creative and fun and their food menu is intentional- not a ton of choices, but delicious choices.…
Bland, disengaged staff that come across very disinterested in interacting with customers. The food was awful. Not even remotely resembling anything with flavor, unless you count the extremely burnt sourdough bread as a flavor. How can a place see bread that burnt and think it’s…
The lattes here are perfect 🤩!! The fresh georgian bread is a MUST and their happy hour on Fridays has been a delightful treat to end a busy week with 🍷
Visited on a rainy morning with my boyfriend, we got breakfast and a beverage. I got an iced vanilla latte (so basic) but I wish I tried one of their specialty drinks they looked delish! We both had a breakfast sandwich and they were fantastic! So filling and well prepared!…
Crema Reviews
You might also like
Little Red Coffee & Catering (Fort Erie)
★ 4.9 (177)
Little Red Coffee & Catering is a genuine neighborhood gem where owner Les has…
Sevens
★ 4.7 (223)
Sevens is the rare neighborhood cafe that nails both the vibe and the…
Remedy House
★ 4.6 (650)
Remedy House is a beloved Buffalo spot that nails the cozy, Instagram-worthy…
Wonder Coffeehouse
★ 4.6 (504)
Wonder Coffeehouse is a whimsical industrial gem in Buffalo where the coffee…