Penny's Coffee Shop

Crema's Take

“Penny's Coffee Shop has earned a loyal following in Buffalo with its balanced approach to both traditional and creative specialty drinks, making it a reliable spot whether you're after a straightforward espresso or something more adventurous like their matcha offerings. The shop distinguishes itself by pairing quality coffee with a solid food program that spans from light bites to full breakfasts and fresh pastries, creating the kind of neighborhood gathering place where you can settle in for a meal, not just a quick caffeine fix. With a 4.3-star rating across hundreds of reviews, it's clearly struck a chord with locals who appreciate its unpretentious warmth and consistency.”