Tomato Pie Cafe
23 N Broad St, Lancaster, PA
Crema's Take
“Tomato Pie Cafe's signature savory pie is worth the trip alone—locals rave about the buttery crust and bright, fresh tomatoes that justify the name. The front-row park views and small-town Lancaster charm make it an ideal spot to linger over cold brew or a full breakfast, whether you're catching up with friends or working solo. It's the kind of place that feels like a secret despite its 4.5-star popularity.”
What to expect
Cold brew standout. A slow-sit, laptop-friendly, outdoor seating spot, good for meetings. Full breakfast, pastries, and light food on the menu. Family friendly.
Google Reviews
We were here on a weekday for lunch and somehow lucked into one of the best tables in the place- front left high top- with a beautiful view of the park and old Wilbur chocolate factory. I ordered the hot roast beef and hubby ordered the tomato pie. I loved my dish, but after…
A nice surprise mid-afternoon. First time visiting Lititz PA and first time here. Great small town country vibe with everything you’d expect from any big city eatery. Cold brew was excellent as was the pumpkin latte (not too sweet like many from the brand name coffee houses we…
whoa! thats one reaaally good tomato pie! ive never tried one before so this was a great treat! crust was so good and the tomatoes were fresh and bursting with flavor. So glad we tried their signature dish! Their cookie butter was good but a bit too sweet for me. Like sugary…
Great location right in the middle of town, nice little breakfast and lunch menu with seasonal options. We had the Summer Berry Salad, the Cilantro Lime Bowl w/ Chicken, and side of the Rosemary Potatoes. Everything was very flavorful but ended up having to go out to eat after.…
One of my wife and my favorite breakfast spots when we vacation in Lititz. The vibe is super cool and laid back, it’s really nice inside and the staff are always great here. On our stay this last week I’ve had the pancakes which were great, the sausage egg wrap which was nice,…
Crema Reviews
You might also like
Rachel's Cafe & Creperie
★ 4.7 (2,799)
Rachel's excels at the thing most cafés get wrong: actually making you want to…
Coffee Co - MillCreek
★ 4.6 (1,172)
Coffee Co is a rare all-day destination where the coffee program and full…
Chestnut Hill Cafe
★ 4.5 (397)
College Treats
★ 4.9 (176)
College Treats nails the fundamentally difficult task of being a casual…