Lancaster Pie & Coffee
136 N Prince St, Lancaster, PA
Crema's Take
“The bourbon pecan pie here is legendary enough to justify a detour alone, and the rotating seasonal selections like pumpkin are executed with real care—this is a place that takes its desserts seriously, not as an afterthought. The coffee is solid and the service is genuinely warm, making it feel like a neighborhood gathering spot rather than a transaction, though seating is tight and prices reflect the quality you're getting. Go expecting to linger over a slice and a cup, not to grab and go.”
What to expect
Classic coffee drinks done right. A slow-sit spot, good for meetings. Pastries on the menu. Family friendly.
Google Reviews
Lancaster Pie & Coffee is outstanding and totally lived up to expectations. My wife and I split three different savory quiches and a slice of the decadent bourbon pecan pie and our taste buds were wowed, all so flavorful and homemade tasting. The staff is so friendly and…
Pretty good. Food can get a little pricey. Limited seating The service is great though! Taste great too!
Lancaster Pie & Coffee is a great small business that adds to the vibe of downtown Lancaster. When I went I purchased a slice of pumpkin pie which is one of my favorites... and also one that I am very picky about. This slice however passed all of my tests, it avoided the trap…
We recently visited Lancaster, and it was such a beautiful place with so many great spots to eat — but Lancaster Pie and Coffee really stood out. This little nook in the wall serves some of the most delicious pies I’ve ever tasted. I’m a sucker for peach pie, and they…
This is a great gem of a place. Modest business but the service is outstanding. The pies are very good. The coffee is spot on (Americano). Comfortable and relaxing.....pie and coffee....I thought I wasn't going to be interested but I like this place a lot! Indoor seating. …
Crema Reviews
You might also like
Lancaster Sweet Shoppe
★ 4.8 (722)
Lancaster Sweet Shoppe excels at seasonal creativity, with rotating ice cream…
College Treats
★ 4.9 (176)
College Treats nails the fundamentally difficult task of being a casual…
Lancaster Beignet Company
★ 4.8 (441)
Lancaster Beignet Company makes their beignets to order, which means you're…
Trolley Line Coffee
★ 4.9 (150)
The baristas here know their regulars so well they'll start making your order…