Lighthouse Keeper's Pantry

Found this place on the way to Ptown. Heard about their seagull special so naturally had to try it out. Pastries were so delicious we came back two days later (mind you it’s a 25 min drive from where we came) and got more and the sandwiches were INSANE. Coffee was delicious as well. There was a small wait but well worth it and you can shop around the front space while waiting (very dangerous, everything is adorable)

Loved the vibe in this store. The line was out the door when we arrived on Sunday morning at 9am but it moved fairly quickly. Had to get the fluffy seagull. To be honest I wasn’t impressed, I never tasted peanut butter. It was ok, I drank it but the hype on this drink is overkill. Their crescents are heavenly. We tried the ham and cheese, the chocolate and the chocolate chunk cookie crescent. They were absolutely delicious. As of this posting I haven’t tried the homemade pop tarts but they are so cute!

Let me start by saying, the wait was about 50 minutes, and the line was long. But from the moment we stepped inside, the warm and welcoming ambience made it easy to settle in and look forward to what was coming. It’s the kind of place that feels cozy upon entering. We ordered two Fluffy Seagulls, a peach tea, blueberry muffins, a bag of Cape Cod granola, and a sandwich. Everything was fresh, beautifully prepared, and bursting with flavor. You can taste the care and quality in every bite. Our total came to $66 with tip, which is on the higher side, but for the freshness and craftsmanship you get, it’s worth every penny. A truly delicious stop that I’d happily wait in line for again.

What a lovely experience! From the staff to the coffee and pastries, this place does it right! The iconic fluffy seagull was worth the hype! Our favorite item was by far the chocolate chunk cookie croissant… best croissant I think I’ve ever had. If you like cookie dough, you will definitely like this item! Poptart was so good but only available Thursday-Sunday 🥰

We came here multiple times during our trip to the Cape and absolutely loved it every time. The Fluffy Seagull Latte —so good! Their breakfast sandwiches are seriously amazing, super tasty and unique. The vibe is really chill and the staff are super friendly. Definitely one of our favorite spots—can’t wait to come back next time we’re in town! Try their hot sauces too!!!