Pink Pony Soft Serve

Took my kids here. Building is really small other than that this place is wonderful. Creative and flavorful will be coming back.

Pink Pony Ice Cream is one of my favorite hidden gems to bring out-of-town family and friends for a taste of local ice cream. The ice cream is incredibly creamy and delicious, and the staff is always kind and efficient. The shop itself is small, so it’s not ideal for hanging out with a big group, but it’s absolutely worth the visit!

“I love the ice cream here! The flavors taste truly homemade and you can really tell the difference compared to the big chain shops. My favorite treat is the cherry-dipped cone and milkshakes, and of course I always get a pup cup for my dog. Such a great locally owned spot.”

This soft serve shop is very cute. It is in a shady neighborhood so I would advise to be vigilant if you’re visiting in the evening. They have two soft serve flavors - vanilla and chocolate. They get their milk from a local dairy which is so cool. Their MSP is the different variety of toppings they offer on their sundae, cones and milkshakes. They had fall season specials going on today - cinnamon, apple pie and marshmallow based toppings. We got hazelnut brownie sundae and vanilla soft serve with sprinkles. They prepare the dishes with utmost care and love. The ice cream was fantastic! There is a lot of customization that can be done and it will satisfy the pickiest of the customers.

Amazing service the two ladies were very charismatic and friendly. We ended up getting the Smores one and a scoop of chocolate ice cream. Beyond delicious. The Marshmallow on top omg! We gave them a tip because they went above and beyond. I dislike most place towards closing throw a big tantrum about servicing clients. Here we were 3 minutes till closing and after a long day I wanted to take my wife for some ice cream. Here they greeted us as soon as we walked in. Also cute banana caution sign