Overbaked

Overbaked

211 S Main St, Newark, DE

★★★★4.4(152 Google reviews)

Crema's Take

Overbaked is a charming Newark bakery-cafe hybrid where pastries and cakes are genuinely exceptional—think pistachio crepe cakes and chocolate bear mousse that look as good as they taste. The inviting dining space draws people in for leisurely sit-downs, and their specialty coffees pair beautifully with their standout baked goods, making it an ideal spot whether you're meeting a friend or hunting for a custom birthday cake.

What to expect

Specialty coffee. A slow-sit spot, good for meetings. Pastries on the menu.

Slow sitMeetingsSpecialty drinksTraditional drinksPastries

Google Reviews

Paris Carr
★★★★3 months ago

Rude, Racist, Rinse, Repeat. While looking for the Turkish bakery, I accidentally found this joint. It seemed ok, and I went there January 29, 2026. I walked into an empty shop, save for two guests on a date, and began to order. I chose the strawberry cream latte and three…

Brianna Roberts
★★★★★3 months ago

Stumbled across this place on google and it did not disappoint. Went and got three desserts and all of them were as good as they looked. I deff recommend the pistachio crepe cake. 😋

Terra B
★★★★★3 months ago

The dining space is so cute and inviting, I wish I took a picture. We got the salted caramel coffee cake and it was divine! Perfect balance of salt and sweet and the cake was moist and spongy. Will definitely be coming back for hubby's birthday cake. I got the Nutella Mocha…

Callie
★★★★a year ago

I went to Overbaked Cafe/Bakery a day or so ago and I want to say it’s pretty great. The cakes are adorable I got the chocolate bear mousse which was adorable and so good! I also got the strawberry cake box which I also liked but the bottom tasted more like straight egg than…

Victoria Reah
★★★★★a year ago

Amazing place! I was searching for the perfect spot to order a birthday cake, and I finally found it! I’ve enjoyed their desserts and coffee in the past, but this was my first time ordering a cake, and I absolutely loved it! The cake turned out perfect—gorgeous and delicious. It…

Crema Reviews

No Crema reviews yet

Been here? Be the first to leave a review in the app.

Write a review on iOS