Brooklyn Bagel At Arsenal
3915 Butler St, Pittsburgh, PA
Crema's Take
“This Arsenal neighborhood spot does New York-style bagels right, with quality ingredients and creative combinations like the Pittsburgher that cater thoughtfully to dietary preferences. Whether you're grabbing a lox bagel loaded with fresh avocado or a breakfast sandwich with crispy hash browns, you'll find the staff genuinely helpful and the energy warm and welcoming. It's the kind of place that delivers on the promise of a proper bagel shop—unpretentious, efficient, and genuinely delicious.”
What to expect
Classic coffee drinks done right. A quick-grab spot, good for meetings. Pastries and light food on the menu. Family friendly.
Google Reviews
A must-visit for vegans who love a greasy breakfast sandwich. I always order the Pittsburgher, sub vegan egg, cheese, and sausage (and it comes with a hashbrown) on a vegan cheddar bagel. Absolutely mind-blowing. I've also had it on a classic everything bagel and it's so good.…
Delicious! I got a blt & a on an everything bagel. Maybe one of the best breakfast sandwiches I have ever had. They have lots of bagel options as well as sandwich choices. We went on a Saturday around 11 and it was not too busy. The place is small so I can see it being hard to…
Brooklyn Bagel is so good. Service is pretty nice. The menu features a variety of breakfast and lunch options, of course featuring delicious New York style bagels. Ingredients are fresh and high quality. When I stopped by on a Saturday morning I tried the Avocado Bagel -which…
Good energy and great food. Staff greeted me promptly and helped me through the menu. Coffee was made quickly and plenty of seating while I awaited my bagel. Location itself is clean and comfortable - appreciated the well stocked station for napkins, coffee add ins, salt…
Great spot. Easy and straightforward menu, sweet service, good food. I got the lox bagel and enhanced it with avocado slices (well invested $2), and the burg bagel which had a patty and hash brown and was satisfying. Lavender latte was surprisingly delicious. Service was patient…
Crema Reviews
You might also like
Trolley Barn Eatery
★ 4.7 (413)
Trolley Barn Eatery is a beloved neighborhood diner where the walls tell…
Balena Bagels
★ 4.8 (134)
Balena Bagels is turning heads in Pittsburgh's South Hills with bagels that…
Brother Andre's Cafe - City Center
★ 5.0 (195)
Brother Andre's pours generous, high-quality coffee with a purpose—every cup…
Peace, Love and Little Donuts Strip District
★ 4.6 (867)
This tiny Strip District gem specializes in made-to-order mini donuts with over…