Brooklyn Bagel At Arsenal
Brooklyn Bagel At Arsenal — photo 2
Brooklyn Bagel At Arsenal — photo 3
Brooklyn Bagel At Arsenal — photo 4
Brooklyn Bagel At Arsenal — photo 5

Brooklyn Bagel At Arsenal

3915 Butler St, Pittsburgh, PA

★★★★4.3(223 Google reviews)

Crema's Take

This Arsenal neighborhood spot does New York-style bagels right, with quality ingredients and creative combinations like the Pittsburgher that cater thoughtfully to dietary preferences. Whether you're grabbing a lox bagel loaded with fresh avocado or a breakfast sandwich with crispy hash browns, you'll find the staff genuinely helpful and the energy warm and welcoming. It's the kind of place that delivers on the promise of a proper bagel shop—unpretentious, efficient, and genuinely delicious.

What to expect

Quick grabTraditional drinksFamily friendlyMeetingsLight foodPastries

Google Reviews

Delta Daley
★★★★★4 months ago

A must-visit for vegans who love a greasy breakfast sandwich. I always order the Pittsburgher, sub vegan egg, cheese, and sausage (and it comes with a hashbrown) on a vegan cheddar bagel. Absolutely mind-blowing. I've also had it on a classic everything bagel and it's so good. The portion size is quite large for a breakfast sandwich and I think it's worth every penny every time. I can't recommend the vegan breakfast sandwiches enough.

Kate Ceraso
★★★★7 months ago

Delicious! I got a blt & a on an everything bagel. Maybe one of the best breakfast sandwiches I have ever had. They have lots of bagel options as well as sandwich choices. We went on a Saturday around 11 and it was not too busy. The place is small so I can see it being hard to find seating in that case. They do have outside seating as well. I also got an iced matcha latte with sugar free vanilla syrup. Everything was great! The service could have been a little friendlier, the person who was working behind the counter seemed a bit uninterested

Gloria
★★★★★10 months ago

Brooklyn Bagel is so good. Service is pretty nice. The menu features a variety of breakfast and lunch options, of course featuring delicious New York style bagels. Ingredients are fresh and high quality. When I stopped by on a Saturday morning I tried the Avocado Bagel -which was very good- and the tasty BLTA Bagel. We also shared the spicy fried potatoes that bring the heat with a chili crunch. I would definitely visit here again. My only complaint was the limited seating, which I understand is unavoidable with the space provided. However, there should be a designated waiting area for customers who are just picking up a to-go order. Many were occupying seating, some even tables fit for four. My party of three who placed an in-house order struggled to squeeze into a nook to eat our meal. Staff should be more proactive and direct to-go customers to wait, standing off to the side, not lounging in seats other paying customers who wish to dine in could be using.

Anthony G
★★★★★a year ago

Good energy and great food. Staff greeted me promptly and helped me through the menu. Coffee was made quickly and plenty of seating while I awaited my bagel. Location itself is clean and comfortable - appreciated the well stocked station for napkins, coffee add ins, salt pepper ketchup etc. I opted for The Burgh - sausage, egg, cheese, and hash brown on your choice of bagel- I went with a well seeded everything bagel. Anyway—— it was delicious and I highly recommend giving Brooklyn Bagel a try!

Jenn Gray
★★★★★2 years ago

Great spot. Easy and straightforward menu, sweet service, good food. I got the lox bagel and enhanced it with avocado slices (well invested $2), and the burg bagel which had a patty and hash brown and was satisfying. Lavender latte was surprisingly delicious. Service was patient and efficient. Not much parking around but with a bit of luck you can find a metered spot

Crema Reviews

No Crema reviews yet

Been here? Be the first to leave a review in the app.

Write a review on iOS