Crumbly Cafe & Bakery

I reached out to the Crumbly team for a custom baby shower cake for my sister and to say they did not disappoint is an understatement! The team was super friendly and helpful in helping us sort through the design quantity and pricing. Then, the gluten free cake they produced was right on the money in terms of aesthetic but also quality and many said it was one of the best cakes (not just gluten free!) they’d had in the city. Thank you so much again to the Crumbly team — you’re now our go-to cake supplier for any occasion.

Crumbly Cafe & Bakery never disappoints! The service is absolutely top-notch, and Mia deserves a special mention—as always. Even with last-minute requests, including customized and gluten-free cakes, she handles everything with such ease and kindness. She’s incredibly helpful and consistently delivers the best quality. We always choose Crumbly for our important members, and they always love the cakes. It’s become our go-to place because we know we can trust the team to get everything just right. Best wishes to the entire team, and especially to Mia—she truly is a gem of a person. 🌟 Highly recommended! Mohit - 🇮🇳

Ordered a custom cake and the bakery did an amazing job! I reached out to them four days before I wanted to pick it up and they were very helpful and accommodating. The cake might've actually been too tall because the rabbit ears got knocked off. But it wasn't too hard to put it back on. Otherwise, it was exactly what we wanted and we were very happy with the service and final product.

Thank you for providing desserts for a baby shower I hosted in NYC but planned it remotely. I based ordering my dessert off of reviews, recommendations and location. I had awesome communication with the Mia and the Crumbly team! My questions were answered in a timely manor and Mia had great suggestions and offerings based on my baby shower theme! The final results were incredible. The carrot cake was beautiful and tasted amazing. I think two people may have ordered from Crumbly since the baby shower, that's how outstanding it was! The macarons were delicious, the cake pops, incredible, and the cupcakes just amazing! The packaging and presentation was great, too! Thank you so much for your delicious treats which helped make the day so perfect. I recommend you to anyone and will be back next time I'm in the city visiting my sister and the new baby! Thanks again!

This is my go-to bakery for gift boxes! Every time I visit a friend’s office, I spend around $100 here to make a beautiful gift box — and it’s always a hit. Everything looks and tastes amazing, and the presentation is just perfect. The staff are kind and helpful, and they make every box feel special. Highly recommend this place for anyone looking for a classy and delicious gift option!