Wanna Cupcake? Bakery Cafe

We ordered cupcakes from Wanna Cupcake in Puyallup for our three kids’ birthday party yesterday, and they were absolutely fantastic. The unicorn and dinosaur cupcakes were not only adorable, but incredibly fresh, moist, and full of flavor. The kids loved them, and the adults were just as impressed. What really makes this special for us is that Wanna Cupcake also made our wedding cake eight years ago—and the quality has stayed just as high. It’s rare to find a bakery that maintains such consistency over the years. From a wedding day to kids’ birthday parties, they’ve been part of some of our favorite family moments. Beautiful designs, great flavors, and clearly a lot of care put into their work. We’ll definitely keep coming back and recommending them to others.

Look at how cute they decorated for new years! Adorable! Always great service, friendly and helpful even if I am stopping in 10 minutes to close. (They are on my way home and cupcakes fix tough work days) Coffee, cupcakes, cookies and even some healthier options if you need a mid day shack. I usually just pop in and out quick but there are seating and table options if you want to dine in and enjoy your treats there.

What an absolutely darling little shop! Tucked in a strip mall alongside a few other businesses, it’s easy to find and has decent parking. The storefront itself is so cute and welcoming, and once you step inside—oh my goodness—it’s even better. The space is spotless, beautifully decorated, and that cozy fireplace? The perfect touch. The staff were incredibly kind, warm, and accommodating—just the sweetest ladies. Now, the food… wow. The scones are my absolute favorite—especially the pumpkin spice and raspberry. They’re to die for! And the cookies? So good I could’ve easily bought one of everything. I highly recommend checking out this charming little bakery. They offer so much more than just treats—there’s coffee, salads, sandwiches, and more. Whether you’re meeting up with a friend, on a date, or just enjoying some “you time,” it’s the perfect spot.

I can’t say enough good things about Wanna Cupcake! This place is an absolute gem and one of my favorite local spots. First off, the drive-thru is such a game changer — it makes grabbing breakfast or a sweet treat so easy, especially when I’m on the go. It’s so convenient to have high-quality bakery items without even leaving the car, and the staff is always so friendly and upbeat, no matter how busy they are. Now let’s talk about the food — because wow. Their toasted everything bagel is to die for! It’s perfectly crisp on the outside, soft and buttery on the inside, and honestly melts in your mouth. It’s one of those things you try once and immediately start craving again. I’ve had plenty of bagels, but this one is life-changing. And then there’s the Magic Bar — my husband’s absolute favorite. It’s rich, gooey, and perfectly balanced with all the right flavors. Every bite feels homemade with love. Whether you’re stopping for breakfast, a coffee, or a sweet treat, Wanna Cupcake never disappoints. The quality, service, and flavor are all five-star worthy. Highly recommend!

We had a fantastic experience ordering from Wanna Cupcake for our wedding! We went with a small cake for our private cake cutting and a variety of mini cupcakes for our guests. Everything was absolutely delicious, and the presentation was perfect. The team was so easy to work with, super responsive and accommodating. I shared a Pinterest photo of the cake I had in mind, and they brought it to life beautifully! It looked exactly how I imagined. Highly recommend Wanna Cupcake for any special event, you won’t be disappointed!