Buttermilk Bakery
1198 N Orange Ave, Winter Park, FL
Crema's Take
“Buttermilk Bakery has earned its cult following with genuinely exceptional pastries that somehow manage to be both light and deeply flavorful—think buttery croissants, standout items like the mortadella hot honey croissant, and treats like peach scones that convert even non-pastry lovers. The vibe here balances perfectly between a quick coffee grab and a lingering sit-down experience with outdoor seating, all backed by consistently fresh daily bakes that draw lines out the door. This Winter Park gem feels like the kind of neighborhood spot that's worth the pilgrimage, whether you're a serious pastry enthusiast or just looking for an exceptionally well-executed coffee and croissant moment.”
What to expect
Classic coffee drinks done right. A slow-sit, quick-grab spot, outdoor seating. Pastries on the menu. Family friendly.
Google Reviews
I tried 2 different croissants and peanut butter cookie, and all were made well not to sweet on the cookie great peanut butter taste. (Love me some peanut butter) It was a soft but firm cookie, almost melt in your mouth. The 🥐 croissants were savery and done well, not to salty…
I’m from Jacksonville and stumbled on Buttermilk Bakery while going down a Reddit rabbit hole looking for “the best dough in Florida” — and wow, Reddit actually came through for once! This place is small but mighty — super organized, cute outdoor seating, and the smell alone…
Heavens to Besty; I’m not even a pastry eater like that but with Buttermilk Bakery, I assure you, I’ve been converted - only for them though. I absolutely love how light yet flavorful everything is - even the DONUT was light… like are you kidding me?! Pure deliciousness. There…
This spot has been on my list for ages and I seriously regret taking this long to try it out. Everything I ordered was nothing short of delicious. The mortadella hot honey croissant was my personal favorite! My friends and I got an assortment and the silence among us was very…
You know this is a popular spot when there is a line out the door! Everything is baked fresh daily. There is a wide selection of savory and sweet baked goods. My favorite today was the peach scone and bread pudding cinnamon roll. The perfect amount of sweetness, without tasting…
Crema Reviews
You might also like
The Glass Knife
★ 4.6 (3,726)
The Glass Knife is a Winter Park gem that beautifully marries elevated pastry…
Lineage Coffee
★ 4.6 (902)
Lineage Coffee earns its reputation as an espresso-focused destination with…
Donut Central - Eats & Coffee
★ 4.6 (610)
This beloved Winter Park spot feels like a genuine neighborhood gathering place…
White Wolf Cafe
★ 4.5 (2,856)
White Wolf Cafe is a charming independent spot in Winter Park that feels like…