Crema's Take
“Schlegl's is a genuinely loved neighborhood bakery where the owner remembers customers and their preferences, turning casual orders into personal experiences—their cake donuts, danishes, and German buttercream cakes are legitimately excellent, though you'll pay a premium for that quality and care. If you're willing to splurge on pastries that taste homemade and feel special, this mom-and-pop spot rewards the trip; if you're budget-conscious, the prices will sting.”
What to expect
Classic coffee drinks done right. A quick-grab spot, good for meetings. Pastries on the menu. Family friendly.
Google Reviews
See all on Google →The employees are nice and helpful. However this place is insanely overpriced. $8 for a small slice of cake and nearly $30 for a coffee cake is crazy. You can get way more for your money elsewhere. The large cookies are hard and don't taste fresh. The employee was doing cashier…
Fantastic cake donuts and danishes! Schlegl's is a treasure. If you are in need of a morning (or afternoon) treat, go there! It's much better than a national chain or a supermarket! (I liked Dominick's cake donuts too, but Shlegl's's are bigger and better!) I only wish I lived…
I decided to purchase a German buttercream cake for a birthday and called to ask about a specific flavor. The owner asked if I had been there before—clearly I had not. I ended up ordering a two-layer cake that came to $90. Later, I realized the owner had added an extra $20 to…
I have been a loyal customer of this bakery for years, and my son absolutely loves their cookies. This morning he asked for a Ramadan cookie, so when I came in, I politely asked the owner if she planned on offering any Ramadan-themed cookies this month. She said she didn’t know…
Mom and Pop style bakery with a variety of sweet and savory goodies. We tried their cookie assortment, some cheese bagels as well as a Neopolitan and Bee Sting. All were delicious and ver more-ish. What i also enjoyed was both the service - super efficient and friendly as…
Crema Reviews
You might also like
Guest House Coffee and Pastries
★ 4.8 (462)
Guest House Coffee and Pastries earns its stellar reviews through genuinely…
Yellow Rose Cafe
★ 4.7 (560)
This cash-only breakfast spot is beloved by regulars for its corned beef…
New York Bagel & Bialy Corporation
★ 4.6 (2,217)
The fresh-baked bagels here draw lines out the door on weekend mornings, and…
Lincoln Cafe
★ 4.6 (260)
This Israeli-run Jewish deli inside a gas station punches way above its…