Melting Hearts Café
Melting Hearts Café — photo 2
Melting Hearts Café — photo 3
Melting Hearts Café — photo 4
Melting Hearts Café — photo 5

Melting Hearts Café

3011 NW Evangeline Thruway, Lafayette, LA

★★★★★4.7(51 Google reviews)

Crema's Take

This Lafayette gem pulls you in with genuinely exceptional pastries (the Berry Seinfeld pie and savory meat pies are legendary) and seriously impressive espresso-based drinks that locals rave about. The cozy, inviting atmosphere makes it perfect for lingering over coffee, and while service can be inconsistent, the sweet and welcoming staff more than make up for it when they're on. It's the kind of place where both the craftsmanship behind the counter and the homemade pastries keep people coming back immediately.

What to expect

Traditional drinksSignature drinksPastriesLight foodEspresso focusedSpecialty drinksSlow sitMeetings

Google Reviews

marissa gomez
★★★★★3 months ago

✨This place should have a 5 star review✨✨✨✨ The Berry Seinfeld pie was absolutely incredible. The meat pies are amongst the best I’ve ever had in my entire life. The pastry has the perfect flakiness to them and the hot honey is chefs kiss to the brisket meat pie. I try to make sure that I guide everyone to Magnolia Pantry if they’ve never been- not a single person I’ve sent there to eat has been underwhelmed, quite the opposite actually. This restaurant is one of Lafayettes most precious hidden gems and I have not had a single bad experience here. The customer service is always exceptional, the service and the atmosphere is very warm and welcoming. The aesthetic gives off fairy vibes and I couldn’t feel more at home. Exceptional food, great pastries, delicious drinks, and wonderful atmosphere….. I have never had a single bad meal from here- I would give it 10 stars if I could. To anyone passing through Lafayette: make sure you stop here for a bite to eat, I promise you won’t regret it💖 Things I’ve tried: Berry Seinfeld Pie Brisket Meat Pie Boudin Meat Pie Quiche Lavender Latte Mocha Latte Lavender Frozen Spiked Lemonade Dragonfruit Frozen Spiked Lemonade- not on the menu as spiked… ask the bartender to add some rum and you’ll be back for more 😜 ** The wakey wakey is something I’ve been wanting to try but every time I get there, it’s sold out…. So, what does that tell you?

Abbigale
★★★★★5 months ago

The guy behind the counter completely ignored us. But eventually another lady came to take our order and was so stinkin’ sweet! She was very kind and helpful with navigating what concoctions we’d like to make our coffees. Absolutely loved our order, and the environment/vibe is SO cozy!💚

Aleia Schexnyder
★★★★★7 months ago

Seriously one of the best coffees I’ve ever had. The environment is cozy and the pies (I had the boudin and brisket ones) were delicious. Staff is very welcoming. Will be returning ASAP.

Emersyn Harris
★★★★★7 months ago

Been to Magnolia Pantry twice now and it’s already one of my favorite places in Lafayette! Everything I’ve gotten so far has been a hit. The food is delicious and the cocktails are so pretty.

Lauren (Rose)
★★★★8 months ago

Cute coffee/tea shop with an inviting, cozy vibe. The oatmeal cookies are out of this world !!! There was a slight discrepancy with purchasing but it was all settled and turned out to be a great experience!

Crema Reviews

No Crema reviews yet

Been here? Be the first to leave a review in the app.

Write a review on iOS