Guilty Pleasures Cafe
1 Depot St, Cold Spring, NY
Crema's Take
“Guilty Pleasures Café has built a devoted following around its house-made cheesecakes and pastries—particularly a baklava cheesecake that locals rave about—paired with surprisingly stomach-friendly coffee that actually feels restorative rather than acidic. The owners are genuinely invested in making regulars feel welcomed, and the food game extends beyond sweets to solid breakfast sandwiches like their bacon, egg, and cheese on NYC everything bagels. If you want a café where the pastry case justifies a dedicated trip and the staff remembers your name, this is worth the detour.”
What to expect
Classic coffee drinks done right. A slow-sit spot, good for meetings. Full breakfast, pastries, and light food on the menu. Family friendly. Parking available.
Google Reviews
Stopped by the new Guilty Pleasures Café location today and had such a great experience. I ordered a bacon, egg, and cheese on their NYC everything bagel and it was 10/10 - fresh, flavorful, and definitely the best I’ve had in the area. The staff was so friendly and…
I wish I could rate higher than 5 stars because this wonderful gem of the Hudson Valley deserves it. I have had their cheesecake and others pastries in the past when they were in their old location and they where unbelievable. I have also gone there to pick up some novelty…
I LOVE THIS PLACE!! It’s walking distance, the staff greet you with a smile when you arrive! The coffee is amazing, and doesn’t hurt my stomach like anywhere else! It’s just enough to wake me up as well. The bagels are FRESH and the seating areas etc are beautifully designed….…
Simply the best place in town. Exceptional customer service. The owners are super friendly and always turn my day around. The cheesecake and other pastries are delicious. They have some yummy food options too (Sandwiches/soups). I ordered several cupcakes here for my mom‘s 70th…
Guilty Pleasure Cheesecakes deserves all the stars! ⭐️ Patrick was amazing in helping me connect with Justine — and she is truly phenomenal. She created a baklava cheesecake for the first time, and it was an absolute hit. Everyone loved it, and it tasted just as incredible as it…
Crema Reviews
You might also like
Village Hands Cafe
★ 4.6 (395)
Village Hands Cafe is a genuine small-town breakfast destination where the…
Bean Runner Cafe
★ 4.6 (312)
Bean Runner trades serious third-wave coffee chops for something more…
The Foundry Rose
★ 3.9 (370)
The Foundry Rose is a serious brunch destination where the pancakes—especially…
Sweetie Pies on Main
★ 4.7 (333)
Sweetie Pies trades in nostalgic New England charm—think quaint vintage decor…