Crema's Take
“Gotham Bagels does authentic New York bagels in Chicago with serious attention to texture and freshness, making their sandwiches (especially the Asiago with bacon, egg and cheese) genuinely worth seeking out on the Magnificent Mile. The staff consistently delivers warm, personalized service that keeps regulars coming back, and their coffee is solid enough to pair well with your breakfast without demanding attention. It's a proper grab-and-go spot with enough charm and consistency to feel like a neighborhood gem, even in a touristy location.”
What to expect
Classic coffee drinks done right. A quick-grab spot, good for meetings. Full breakfast, pastries, and light food on the menu. Family friendly. Parking available.
Google Reviews
See all on Google →Great NYC bagel spot in Chicago near the Magnificent Mile. I really enjoyed all their sandwiches. Was very quick and convenient. Would definitely be back! Only thing I was not crazy for was the pizza bagel. Everything else was really good!
Best bagels in the city 🥯. Always fresh and with the perfect texture. Great coffee too. Shoutout to Anthony Alizé and Elias for their consistently great service. They always have the best playlists and curate immaculate vibes.
One of the best bagel sandwiches we have had. Steady crowd but not overwhelming for a Saturday morning. Friendly and helpful staff. Asiago bagel with bacon, egg and cheese Asiago bagel with egg and pastrami Highly recommend if you’re in the area.
I love this place. My sister is next door at the cancer center, life has been “rough” lately but I always make it a point to stop in here. The team never fails to make my morning a little lighter. They are the friendliest bunch of people, singing, dancing and vibing with the…
This place is really good! Eli (red hair/glasses) was super helpful at helping me decide what to order. The entire staff was so friendly and atmosphere was warm and inviting. My food and latte were very good! Definitely recommend Gotham Bagels on Superior St.
Crema Reviews
You might also like
The Bakehouse Chicago
★ 4.7 (250)
The Bakehouse Chicago runs on genuine warmth—their baristas treat every order…
the beelove cafe
★ 4.6 (123)
Beelove Cafe is a genuinely inviting neighborhood spot with staff that actually…
Robust Coffee Lounge
★ 4.4 (1,493)
Robust's vintage local road sign collection and bacon-scented morning…
Goddess and the Baker, 181 W Madison
★ 4.3 (401)
This downtown Chicago bakery cafe wins you over with a retro-nostalgic…