1872 Cafe

Crema's Take

“This beloved Rochester staple has earned its loyal following with consistently excellent traditional coffee drinks and a no-nonsense approach that gets you quality caffeine fast. The 4.3-star rating across nearly 500 reviews speaks to its reliable execution—locals clearly trust this spot for their everyday coffee fix. It's the kind of place that does the fundamentals right and doesn't overcomplicate things, making it perfect for anyone who wants a solid cup without the fuss.”