Poppy Bakery
2021 E Ivanhoe Pl, Milwaukee, WI
Crema's Take
“Poppy Bakery is a beloved neighborhood gem that's earned its reputation as Milwaukee's best through consistently exceptional, impossibly fresh baked goods that keep locals returning weekly. The warm, welcoming atmosphere strikes that perfect balance between a quick coffee grab and a leisurely spot to linger, with a line that moves fast enough to make the wait feel like part of the charm rather than a hassle. Whether you're stopping by for a traditional espresso drink and a buttery pastry or settling in for a family morning, you'll find staff who clearly care and seasonal rotations that give you reason to keep coming back.”
What to expect
Classic coffee drinks done right. A slow-sit, quick-grab spot, good for meetings. Pastries on the menu. Family friendly.
Google Reviews
Such a great addition to the neighborhood! I’ve been to Poppy bakery three times and am impressed every single time. There is always a line, but it moves fast and is 100% worth the wait. The staff is always super friendly and the bake goods are top notch. The focaccia bread is…
Easily takes the spot as the best bakery I’ve been to in & around Milwaukee. Got multiple items to try out and everything was delicious and moist. I don’t even like olives but still loved the focaccia bread I got for someone else. Will definitely be back to try other items
First time here. Have been wanting to come since they opened and were reviewed in the paper. Came on a Sunday morning before noon, and there was a line pretty much out the door. It didn't take very long to get to the counter. As you wait, you get to check out all the amazing…
First time trying Poppy Bakery and we will definitely be back! When we arrived, line was out the door but for good reason, as the pastries we tried were out of this world! Line moved quickly and we were in and out in no time, but either way, definitely worth the wait. We tried…
We have come here almost every single weekend since they have opened because it is that good! The baked goods are always incredibly fresh and delicious. I particularly like that they have some rotating seasonal flavors so that there's always something new to try. My personal…
Crema Reviews
You might also like
Sprocket Cafe
★ 4.7 (254)
Sprocket Cafe is a wonderfully quirky neighborhood gem adorned with rustic…
Allie Boy’s Bagelry & Luncheonette
★ 4.6 (536)
This beloved Milwaukee spot masterfully balances the energy of a quick-grab…
Sils Mini Donuts
★ 4.6 (236)
Sils Mini Donuts is a charming neighborhood gem that doubles as a retro arcade…
Hifi Cafe
★ 4.5 (270)
This charming Bayview neighborhood gem strikes an effortless balance between a…