Michelles Brown Bag Cafe
630 S Orange Ave, Sarasota, FL
Crema's Take
“Michelle's Brown Bag Cafe is a beloved neighborhood gem where impeccably fresh ingredients shine in every bite, from their legendary egg sandwiches to house-made pastries and carefully crafted paninis. The owner and staff create such a genuinely warm, welcoming atmosphere that what could be a simple breakfast spot becomes the kind of place you want to linger with friends or family, making it worth the slight detour off the main path.”
What to expect
Google Reviews
The best egg sandwich I have ever eaten. The ingredients are extremely fresh. The 9 grain toast was amazing. Owner is super friendly and accommodating. The atmosphere is adorable. I would eat a meal here every day if I could. Simply amazing.
A little off the beaten path, but totally worth it! We were walking around the area and wanted something small but yummy. The bread was fresh and I was able to get half a sandwich. It was stacked so high, I almost couldn’t get my mouth around it. And the pickles are to die for. Loved!
Lovely little spot, the people working there were sooo friendly and welcoming. great food too, awesome selection of sandwiches and paninis. little pricey but the ambiance makes up for it.
Had a nice outing with my grandma. Told her about Michelle’s brown bag since Selby Gardens had ordered from here and it was amazing. First time eating inside their actual restaurant and it was just as amazing. Homemade and very tasty, atmosphere and customer service is amazing. Would highly recommend this place to any friend or family member looking to have a nice lunch or breakfast
Such a great spot! They've been around for years, just not always at this location. They were formerly downtown on main Street. They're still close to main Street. The ingredients are always fresh and the menu is super creative! Cozy dining experience, super friendly staff! Ample parking in the back and Street parking out front. Close to Selby Gardens. The homemade chips are delectable! Homemade cookies, and daily specials 🙌👍 Highly recommend!! I'm going to eat my way down the board and add food photos! Oh and the pickles, they don't chimp on their pickles spheres! It's literally half a pickle!! 🥒 I forgot to mention the potato salad, it's wicked good 👍 👍
Crema Reviews
You might also like
Merci Café
★ 4.9 (514)
Merci Café brings an authentic slice of French charm to Sarasota with expertly…
Bagels And Brews Cafe
★ 4.9 (190)
This beloved Sarasota gem has earned its stellar reputation through genuinely…
Sun Garden Cafe
★ 4.7 (1,370)
Sun Garden Cafe transforms a casual Siesta Key breakfast into an event, with…
Original Word of Mouth
★ 4.7 (1,123)
This beloved Sarasota breakfast and lunch spot nails the classic diner…