Peachey's Baking Co
4800 S Tamiami Trl, Sarasota, FL
Crema's Take
“Peachey's Baking Co. is a Sarasota gem where the donuts are genuinely exceptional—soft, melt-in-your-mouth creations that inspire hour-long drives and devoted return visits. Beyond the standout glazed donuts and pretzels, they roast a solid cup of coffee that pairs perfectly with their fresh pastries, and the whole vibe welcomes families looking for a warm, quality breakfast spot that actually delivers on the hype.”
What to expect
Google Reviews
Fresh, warm, melt-in-your mouth glazed donuts. The best I've ever had, and I've had a lot! 🤤 Pretzels are equally amazing and coffee is good too! (No donut pic because they disappeared too fast! 😄) It has become a Florida vacation must have for us! You won't regret it! Fantastic service! Note: seating is mostly outdoors! 🌞
Peaches Baking Co. is a 20/10 every time! The donuts are absolutely fire — so soft, fresh, and unbelievably delicious. I especially love when they come to the Florida Strawberry Festival each year. It’s so close to home and the perfect chance to get my donut fix!
A family favorite!! We drove an hour on our family vacation just for these donuts & pretzels!! 🥨 🍩☕️ This week they had a special birthday cake doughnut, and the kids loved it! They also gave me a free coffee to go along with the purchase of a Peachy’s sweater. I was surprised by how good the latte was! On top of the amazing treats the facility is beautiful and clean, and the staff are incredibly kind. I’ve had peachy donuts before at our state fair and waited in long lines for them, It was great being able to go to their store today!
I would say this is the best donut in the area, but in all honesty, it's the best donut I have ever had, Anywhere! You are not going to find a more fresh, soft and melt in your mouth donut. Its like a hot and ready Krispy creme but 1000x better. The pretzel is pretty good as well, the mustard sauce makes it great.
Prior to their store opening, I had tried these donuts. Supporting local small businesses is something I'm always happy to do. Nevertheless, I find their prices to be steeper than the value of their food. The pretzel was decent, but a bit too oily for my taste. The provided mustard was a highlight. If you enjoy a doughier donut then you'll likely appreciate these. This time around the donut in my opinion was slightly undercooked. I agree with another reviewer that the donut is somewhat different from the food truck. The line to get in can be long, but it generally moves quickly.
Crema Reviews
You might also like
Sweets Coffee House & Gallery
★ 4.6 (987)
Sweets Coffee House & Gallery is a beloved downtown Sarasota institution that…
Siesta Pops
★ 4.7 (40)
Siesta Pops is a charming Sarasota spot that's genuinely obsessed with handmade…
Bagels And Brews Cafe
★ 4.9 (190)
This beloved Sarasota gem has earned its stellar reputation through genuinely…
Elixir Tea House
★ 4.8 (545)
Nestled in Sarasota, this enchanting tea house transforms the traditional tea…