Fairy Cakes Cupcakery
289 Parkside Ave, Buffalo, NY
Crema's Take
“This welcoming Buffalo bakery excels at custom dessert creations, with reviewers consistently praising the precision and artistry behind everything from personalized wedding cakes to themed cupcakes and macarons that taste as thoughtful as they look. The staff genuinely cares about getting every detail right, whether you're stopping in for a quick pastry or trusting them with a major celebration, and visitors consistently note the clean, fresh atmosphere that makes it feel like a genuinely kind space. It's the kind of neighborhood spot where quality execution meets real personal attention, making it perfect for both everyday treats and those moments that matter.”
What to expect
Classic coffee drinks done right. A quick-grab spot, good for meetings. Pastries on the menu. Family friendly.
Google Reviews
So impressed with the selection of desserts I picked up today! Everything I’ve tried was executed perfectly. The strawberry macaron had a lovely flavor – not overpowering but distinctly strawberry. The fruit tart was luscious, and the fruit was fresh. They bake with care and…
Fairy Cake Bakeshop is the sweet spot in Buffalo. The place was very clean, fresh and the overall tone was welcoming the second I walked in. The staff were genuinely kind and respectful. There was no rushing, no attitude, just good people who seem happy to be there. Met the…
My husband and I went with Fairy Cakes for our wedding based on a recommendation from our photographer and we had a really great experience with them! They were open to our request for a mixture of a small cake for cutting, mini cupcakes, and mini pies, and were able to…
Our wedding cake came out absolutely beautiful and looked exactly like the inspiration picture I showed them! They got every detail I asked for. It also tasted really amazing, and everyone loved it! The cream cheese filling was very yummy. I also appreciated that the process to…
I ordered custom cookies and cupcakes for my nieces baby shower. They exceeded my expectations- the custom work was beautiful to go with her baby in bloom theme! Everyone raved about the flavor of the vanilla cupcake it was so moist and each cupcake was a piped into a flower!…
Crema Reviews
You might also like
BreadHive Bakery & Cafe
★ 4.7 (865)
The Shania sandwich is so legendarily good that people make detours to Buffalo…
Wonder Coffeehouse
★ 4.6 (504)
Wonder Coffeehouse is a whimsical industrial gem in Buffalo where the coffee…
The Lunch Box Buffalo
★ 4.6 (48)
This Buffalo mainstay has earned genuine loyalty with thoughtfully made lattes,…
The Bean on Hertel
★ 4.4 (162)
This Hertel Avenue gem shines brightest as a welcoming third space where dog…