Tilly Bagel Shop

Really liked the bagels here. I ordered half a dozen but only got 5 and the small cream cheeses didn’t have labels so it was a little hard to know which was which. Also kinda pricey I got “a dozen” and 4 small cream cheeses for about $35 with tip. Came to Chicago for a small weekend trip but I’m not too sure I would go back. Staff was friendly

Bagel flavors I’ve never seen and sandwich options that aren’t average. Everything here was great. The bagel was nicely toasted, filling well made, and all of the flavors were so interesting. I’ll definitely be back. One thing I’d change: the little puff seats around short tables in the middle. It makes for a good change in table heights, but don’t seem like actual seating options.

Sadly, the only redeeming quality here was the bagel itself. I ordered a sausage and egg bagel, and the egg had the texture of jello, not exactly the breakfast vibe I was going for. The sausage was so dry it could’ve doubled as a coaster. If you actually want something edible (and affordable), do yourself a favor and go to The Great American Bagel just half a mile away. Trust me, your taste buds will thank you.

Stumbled upon this place and didn’t realize it’s a famous bagel shop. Wanted a breakfast sandwich to hold the wife and I in the morning. Got the Tilly crisp bagel (never heard this combo before and highly recommend ) with an onion cream cheese, bacon, and scrambled eggs. Great chew and texture to the bagel. The combo of everything else was just a classic. Will be back if we make it back to Chicago and need a bagel sandwich.

I genuinely enjoyed visiting this place! The space, the food—everything was great. They bake the bagels fresh right in front of you, and offer unique cream cheese and bagel options that are really exciting. I also appreciated the self-serve station where you can add different syrups and milk to your drink however you like. Plus, they offer online ordering, which is super convenient. Also, the prices are pre reasonable! I came here alone, but I’ll definitely bring my friends next time!