Niyyah Coffee
Niyyah Coffee — photo 2
Niyyah Coffee — photo 3
Niyyah Coffee — photo 4
Niyyah Coffee — photo 5

Niyyah Coffee

6160 N Rural St, Indianapolis, IN

★★★★★4.8(56 Google reviews)

Crema's Take

This cozy Indianapolis gem punches above its weight with genuinely exceptional drinks that go beyond the usual coffee shop fare, especially their fresh-ground matcha that locals rave about as the best in town. The baristas actually listen and care—they'll chat with you about your taste preferences and create something custom rather than just ringing up an order, all while maintaining a warm, unhurried vibe perfect for lingering with a laptop or sinking into their couch. It's the kind of place that feels like a well-kept secret, with thoughtful natural lighting and creative seasonal drinks that prove specialty coffee doesn't need flashy branding to win people over.

What to expect

Laptop friendlySpecialty drinksTraditional drinksSlow sitSignature drinksMatcha & teaEspresso focusedPastries

Google Reviews

Kevin Mounts
★★★★★2 months ago

Niyyah coffee is always a wonderful experience. Their entire menu of drink items are exceptional. This goes without being said, they have the best matcha in town. Not batched like those other places. Handmade ceremonial matcha made fresh each order. A++

Micaela Eberly
★★★★★3 months ago

The staff was so friendly. The girl who helped us quickly pointed out best sellers and asked more about what kinds of drinks we liked. She was awesome. It's a small place but we sat on the couch for a couple hours and it was a nice vibe.

Evelyn Mauser
★★★★3 months ago

I love the coffee here, and think that the menu options are all really fun and creative. The inside is also really cute with good natural lighting and a variety of sitting options. My only issue with it is that all of the times I’ve been there, no music has been playing in the background making it uncomfortably quiet if you don’t have earbuds to put it. Seriously it’s like so quiet it feels loud haha. I would suggest some low music in the background of some sort just to make it a more comfortable place to be. Other than that, I love Niyyah!

Cortez Woods
★★★★★4 months ago

Very friendly staff that helped me find a drink on the menu I would like and modified it to better fit my tastes after chatting a bit. Drink was very flavorful and not overly sweet. The cake was fluffy and delicious too! We ate inside and it was very clean, bright and welcoming. Pictured are the Strawberry Fields Matcha and Biscoff Cake.

Steve Hill
★★★★★a year ago

Nice little coffee shop with a quiet, clean aesthetic. Great tasting coffee with no frills and friendly, helpful baristas. You wouldn’t necessarily know this place is here because the exterior doesn’t have a sign other than a door decal. However, it’s worth coming here over Starbucks, particularly if you’re looking for something quiet. The prices are generally better as well. Hopefully the community will support this shop as more people realize it’s here.

Crema Reviews

No Crema reviews yet

Been here? Be the first to leave a review in the app.

Write a review on iOS