Ithaca Coffee Company

The coffee and service were good. However, I would be likely to return if there wasn’t a $1.50 upcharge for alternative milk, which is steep relative to other businesses. I’m aware non-dairy milk is more expensive, but not $1.50 per serving more expensive. It feels exploitative for a business to profit off food allergies.

The coffee here is really good, there is good hot food as well as pastries. They also sell a lot of interesting little treats like cookies and marzipan. The parking lot has plenty of spaces and is really nice since most other coffee shops in town only have street parking.

I don't normally leave reviews on too many restaurants but I needed to write one about my experience today. I went into this cafe by myself, something else I don't normally do and have a great experience. The atmosphere was just busy enough but also quiet, friendly workers and my latte was yummy and they had lots of other goodies I ended up buying also. But the most important thing is I am currently on crutches. After asking the guy helping me if he would mind if I went to my car to grab a different bag to carry everything he offered to help me and bring the bag out to my car for me. They were not busy at the time but something I found to be a very nice offer none the less. I will absolutely be back frequently. I did not try the food today but everything looked yummy.

The space is great. Very clean, and well curated with nice furniture, and a great gift shop selection. The coffee is also pretty good. Staff was really friendly and attentive. My only critique is the egg used on their breakfast sandwiches. Soggy, no flavor and very similar to a gas station sandwich. I was quite confused, as everything else seemed like they care about their quality. Baked goods next time🙂

The coffee is quite good and they have several tasty food items on offer as well. The staff are friendly and the store has a nice vibe. Prices are fair.