Colin's Coffee
2812 Fishinger Rd, Upper Arlington, OH
Crema's Take
“Colin's Coffee in Upper Arlington has carved out a loyal following as the neighborhood's creative coffee destination, where signature drinks like the Banana Bread Latte and Buckeye Madness showcase a real commitment to flavor beyond the standard menu. The newly expanded shared space with Daily Growler offers a relaxed, open atmosphere with plenty of natural light and seating—perfect for lingering with friends or getting to know the personable staff, including owner Colin himself, who clearly values the regulars who stop by. With solid pastries, light food, and an eclectic decor that rewards a closer look, this is the kind of spot where the coffee tastes great and the human connection feels genuine.”
What to expect
Google Reviews
Love this place. Meet up with friends for coffee and this is our go-to right now. Had the banana bread latte and it was perfect, not too sweet and lots of banana bread flavor. Plenty of seating indoors and out and lots of parking.
Visited the new, shared space for Colin's Coffee. I ordered the Buckeye Madness. Drink was quickly prepared and tasted great. There is more seating at Daily Growler then the former location. The new location lacks some charm from the previous location.
Really awesome local coffee shop that I randomly discovered in UA. Firstly, there is a large parking lot with an abundance of parking. The shop is open space concept with glass windows and nice standing tables (helpful for people who have a hard time sitting like me, especially with caffeine). The coffee was fresh and warm. Enjoyed a cup of Joe with a McRoy everything bagel that hit the spot. Very friendly staff. I’d pick this place over a mainstream coffee shop any day.
Clearly a well established coffee shop and it's easy to see why. There were regulars that stopped in to talk to Colin. Staff was nice and the coffee is great! It's fun to look at the eclectic decor that's around the shop and they also sell bags of coffee. The patio was my favorite because there is so much room for people or groups to be outside.
There are two guys who work there, on of which is the owner. The other guy is the one I met and he was super friendly. Lends a personal element to the service. He made me a great breakfast bagel sandwich, and I had a solid cup of their medium roast coffee. I really liked the feel of the interior too. Very tuned into the community and local events. Very comfortable appearance.