Mud Creek Coffee
571 Castle Dr, Sherwood, WI
Crema's Take
“Mud Creek Coffee is a reliable pit stop in Sherwood where the specialty coffee and hand-crafted sandwiches are worth the slight premium you'll pay—just know that consistency can be a bit of a gamble depending on the day. The friendly service and clean, welcoming atmosphere make it a pleasant place to linger over a mocha or grab something hearty for the road, with regulars particularly praising the quality and care that goes into each sandwich. It's the kind of place where you might discover your new favorite specialty drink one visit and find the execution a little off the next, but the genuine effort and good bones keep people coming back.”
What to expect
Google Reviews
I go to the Sherwood location often and always order the same speciality coffee. Sometimes the drink is great, but other times, not so much. It’s very hit or miss if I am going to get a good drink or not. The drink I got today tasted watered down with no flavor. Very disappointing as I pay extra to have additional flavoring added so not sure if it’s even really being added. The service used to be great but it’s definitely not the same lately as I’ve had my drink made incorrectly a few times the last couple of months and they added an item I specifically asked to exclude. The last time it happened, they realized it was wrong as they were handing it to me, but I was in the drive through with cars behind me so just took it anyway. I hope they can turn things around as this is a place I normally really enjoy.
Just got the drip coffee. It was decent once it cooled down, though very hot. Good value for the price.
Pulled off for a coffee and was so happy to get a good coffee! You just never know when you stop somewhere, but I can happily say I will enjoy this mocha as I keep tootling down the road on my trip. Thank you. (And they have Colectivo bagged for sale!)
This was a nice find. The food and coffee were very good. The service was very friendly and the place is nice and clean. My only suggestion would be for a different type of salsa to go with the breakfast burrito.
Best food ever. Love going here. A little pricey vs fast food places, but sandwich is so much better. Have had several and all are very good, You can tell they are special and hand Crafted to look as great as they taste. Especially like the pasta side dish. Wife likes the coffee and atmosphere.