Collegetown Bagels

Crema's Take

“This beloved Ithaca institution opens early to fuel the community with straightforward, well-executed coffee and fresh bagels, making it the perfect spot to grab a quick caffeine hit before class or work. It's where locals linger over their cups and catch up with friends, striking that sweet spot between efficient service and a genuinely welcoming atmosphere that keeps people coming back across generations. The pastries and light food options complement the solid coffee program, though it's really the reliability and warmth of the place—not complicated specialty drinks—that earns it such devoted loyalty.”