Crema's Take
“Pegasus has genuine charm—an ivy-covered storefront and cozy interior that regulars love as a reliable breakfast-and-coffee stop near the water—but the coffee itself lands as pleasant rather than memorable, and you'll find inconsistency in both the drinks and staff warmth. It's solidly worth visiting if you're in the area for the atmosphere and food, just don't expect specialty-grade espresso or consistent hospitality.”
What to expect
Classic coffee drinks done right. A slow-sit, laptop-friendly, quick-grab, outdoor seating spot, good for meetings. Full breakfast and pastries on the menu. Dog friendly. Family friendly. Parking available.
Google Reviews
See all on Google →A beautiful little coffee shop tucked inside an ivy-covered building. The cozy interiors give it a warm, welcoming feel and make it a nice place to relax for a while. The coffee was decent, though not particularly memorable. What stood out more was the friendly baristas and the…
The best coffee shop on the island! Such a great place to grab a coffee and breakfast sandwich in the morning next to the water. Be warned that this place is blowing up in TikTok right now (pumped for the shop) but that means for the customer you should try to stop by real…
I stopped by Pegasus Coffee House during my visit to Bainbridge Island, but unfortunately it was closed when we arrived, so I didn’t get a chance to try their coffee or food. From the outside, it looked like a charming, cozy local café with a lot of character. It had that…
Very cozy cute atmosphere coffee shop with some good seasonal menu options. We tried orange cardamom latte. It was very flavorful. Cashier staff was not very friendly. We requested latte art for in house mug but he just ignored us and did not bother saying anything. Bariata…
First stop after getting off the ferry and first time on Bainbridge Island! Very cute on the outside and homey on the inside. Friendly staff and quick service, there was no wait at all for a Friday at 9am. Not only was the coffee great but so were the couple food items we got…
Crema Reviews
You might also like
Austin Chase Coffee
★ 4.6 (470)
The real draw here is the welcoming, home-like atmosphere and genuinely kind…
Hollydays
★ 4.9 (146)
The owner's white coffee cold brew and creative signature drinks like the…
Hot Java Café
★ 4.5 (415)
Hot Java Café has earned a devoted local following largely on the strength of…
MOVE Espresso + Blend
★ 4.9 (281)
The owners here actually remember their regulars by name and create the kind of…