Cutthroat Bagel Company
28 Lupfer Ave, Whitefish, MT
Crema's Take
“Tucked inside a charming converted house, this spot has earned serious bagel credibility from folks who grew up in the NYC/NJ bagel belt—reviewers consistently say these chewy-outside, soft-inside bagels rival or surpass what they remember from the East Coast. The salt and seed bagel with fresh-cooked eggs, cheese, and bacon seems to be the legendary sandwich that keeps people coming back, though the plain bagel with lox and capers is equally praised for letting quality toppings shine. It's the kind of place where you can grab your coffee and bagel quick, or settle in for a slow breakfast in a genuinely welcoming atmosphere.”
What to expect
Classic coffee drinks done right. A slow-sit spot, quick-grab. Full breakfast, pastries, and light food on the menu.
Google Reviews
Whitefish should be so lucky to have this bagel shop. It's truly a delight, friendliest service that is genuine and cozy spot to eat your treat. Bagels are tender, chewy with the ever slight crisp. Sandwiches are yummy and piled high with quality ingredients. There is so much…
I can’t decide which I loved more, the bagel or the experience. Let’s start with the bagel - the perfect, tough exterior balanced with a chewy and almost light middle. It was expertly paired with the perfect (and generous) and amount of cream cheese. 10/10! The most memorable…
Phenomenal bagels. No need to toast them (which is a great sign.) Baked daily, full of flavor, and so chewy in all the best ways. The eggs on the sandwich are notably stellar too - creamy and smooth which isn't an easy feat. My dad grew up in NJ, so we visit NJ/NY regularly and…
We loved dining at this cute restaurant inside a converted house! The seedy salty bagel is, well, very salty! We recommend the plain bagel to bring out the flavorful toppings like the lox and capers. Lovely sandwiches with fresh herbs, a well balanced satisfying meal.
This place has the BEST bagels in the Flathead. Hands down. The salt and seed bagel with the eggs cheese and bacon was one of the best bagel sandwiches I've ever had. We will be back!
I grew up in the NYC/NJ area, and when you leave there you spend the rest of your life missing and searching for 3 things, a GOOD Pizza, a GOOD Chesesteak and GOOD Bagels. Sadly, the search for pizza and cheesesteaks continues....but, THANKFULLY Cutthroat Bagel knocks it out of…
Crema Reviews
You might also like
Montana Coffee Traders
★ 4.6 (1,072)
Nestled in Whitefish near Glacier National Park, this espresso-focused coffee…
Somers Bay Cafe
★ 4.5 (456)
Tucked into Whitefish, this beloved breakfast spot nails the cozy farmhouse…
Fleur Bake Shop
★ 4.7 (350)
Fleur Bake Shop is a charming neighborhood gathering spot where French pastries…
Montana Coffee Traders
★ 4.6 (655)
Nestled in Whitefish, Montana Coffee Traders earns its 4.6-star reputation with…