The Mustard Club
2829 2nd Ave S, Birmingham, AL
Crema's Take
“This European-style café in Pepper Place crafts exceptional house-made sandwiches (think porchetta and Sicilian varieties) that justify the premium pricing with genuinely fresh, scratch-made ingredients. The cozy, intimate space—complete with a comfortable banquet bench and welcoming bar area—makes it perfect for lingering over a specialty coffee or light bite, backed by consistently top-notch service that keeps locals excited about what's coming next on their expanding menu.”
What to expect
Google Reviews
A heads up, this place is definitely on the pricier side when it comes to lunch, but the quality is there! Super fresh ingredients made from scratch and the service was top notch! An excellent new spot that’s compliments Pepper Place well!
Absolutely killer sandwiches and top-notch service. Fantastic addition to Pepper Place, and I'm excited to come back to try more things as their menu expands.
The Sicilian sandwich was delicious - great blend of savory and sweet flavors. The interior is cute and cozy with a comfortable banquet bench along one wall. There’s also a nice bar area for ordering takeout, coffee, or cocktails. There are also a few tables for outside seating. Staff was very friendly, and service was great.
European style cafe with the most delicious sandwiches in Birmingham!
Porchetta sandwich was incredible!
Crema Reviews
You might also like
Seeds Coffee Co. - Homewood
★ 4.8 (705)
Seeds Coffee in Homewood is an espresso-focused gem where the cappuccinos are…
Maple Avenue Coffee House
★ 4.9 (106)
Maple Avenue Coffee House nails the cozy neighborhood vibe where you can linger…
Baba Java - The Village at Meadowbrook
★ 4.9 (79)
This Highway 280 gem has earned serious credibility among espresso purists with…
Gilchrist
★ 4.8 (95)
Gilchrist is a beloved Birmingham institution that transports you back in time…