Mr. Yo's Donut
Mr. Yo's Donut — photo 2
Mr. Yo's Donut — photo 3
Mr. Yo's Donut — photo 4
Mr. Yo's Donut — photo 5

Mr. Yo's Donut

1296 Main St, Windsor, CO

★★★★4.4(457 Google reviews)

Crema's Take

While Mr. Yo's Donut earns praise for genuinely excellent donuts that locals say rival Lamar's—especially their perfectly executed plain glaze—the shop struggles with inconsistent hours that have frustrated many customers despite posted times. If you can catch them open, the fresh, quality pastries and friendly vibe make it worth the drive from nearby towns, though calling ahead seems like the wisest move before making the trip.

What to expect

Traditional drinksFamily friendlyParkingPastriesDrive-thruQuick grab

Google Reviews

ray martinez
★★★★2 months ago

Was excited to try them. Drive from Greeley just to be extremely disappointed. I came during hours posted online and at store and the door was locked nobody to be seen. Really sucks. Would give a negative if I could.

wa Kish
★★★★★3 months ago

Always a crap shoot. You never know when they’ll be open. I have come by multiple times when they’re expected to be open, only to find they are not. Maybe a blessing in disguise. I would recommend looking at other options. Wanted to follow up on the owners response. In the past 6 weeks I have come by at 5:15-5:20 AM. No lights, sign says closed. So I did check the hours prior to checking. Twice is more than fair.

Aaron Decker
★★★★★2 years ago

I have gone to Mr. Yo's multiple times and been happy with my order each time. This time I got the glazed donuts for a work event. Three dozen donuts and all were consistent and taste quality and ability to disappear at a work event. Easy parking and quick in and out with my order. Multiple people working at 7:00 a.m. to take care of customers. I will go back again. Enjoy!

Birder Hiking
★★★★3 years ago

These donuts my husband and I both agreed were better than Lamars. They were soft and fresh. I liked the plain glaze. I feel like you can really tell a donut spot by their plain glaze. Croissant glazed was fun and i enjoyed that one as well. The apple fritter was too sweet for my liking. I like when the apple chunks still taste like apple not just cinnamon sugar. Very small selection at 11am.

Ryan Carey
★★★★★5 years ago

Fresh and Delicious donuts! Don't let the line scare you. It is a testament to the quality of this donut shop and we'll worth it. Store is open for Drive thru but you can place an order and pickup in lobby. Lobby is not open for ordering, only for pickup. This is one of our favorite local spots for donuts. You need to be here early to be sure they will have want you are wanting. They sell out fast! High demand!

Crema Reviews

No Crema reviews yet

Been here? Be the first to leave a review in the app.

Write a review on iOS