Bennison's Bakery
1000 Davis St, Evanston, IL
Crema's Take
“This nearly-century-old Evanston institution captures that perfect neighborhood bakery feeling—cozy and genuine, with genuinely impressive pastries that justify the loyal regulars who keep coming back. Fair warning: weekend mornings get packed and a bit hectic, but if you time it right, you'll find a warm, unpretentious spot that feels like it belongs to the community rather than chasing trends. The coffee is straightforward and traditional, perfectly suited to pairing with their substantial baked goods and lingering over a quiet weekday morning.”
What to expect
Classic coffee drinks done right. A slow-sit, quick-grab spot, good for meetings. Pastries on the menu. Family friendly.
Google Reviews
It’s an okay bakery. The food is decent but not something that makes me want to keep coming back. The service is weird - most of the employees don’t seem to want to work here, and so I never experienced a friendly and welcoming atmosphere. The store itself is charming and nicely…
A true Evanston staple. Bennison’s has been around for almost a century and has stayed true to its family-owned practices. The interior is small, but the bakery items are not. You’ll be treated to the fresh scent of bread, butter, coffee, and rich caramelization as soon as you…
I needed something really fast, and this bakery did not disappoint! Service was friendly and they had a wide variety of pastries that all looked delicious!
I live in the area and go here quite often - it’s such a lovely place! Warm inside with a variety of wonderful baked goods. I’m actually surprised to see people complain about the price, I think they’re quite fair overall. They’re a local bakery serving treats daily since the…
Went on a Saturday morning. Place was packed and there was nowhere to sit. Staff trying to herd people through. Stated to set an understanding of the vibe. If you don't like pressure or a little stress ordering, go somewhere with table service. We had Paczkis and Croissants.…
Crema Reviews
You might also like
Smack Dab Chicago
★ 4.8 (1,528)
Smack Dab has mastered the art of the neighborhood gathering spot where the…
Crepe O'Clock
★ 5.0 (90)
This charming Evanston spot pairs impeccably crafted espresso drinks with…
Free Flow Kitchen
★ 5.0 (35)
Free Flow Kitchen in Evanston feels like stepping into someone's warm,…
Cupitol Coffee & Eatery
★ 4.5 (2,021)
Cupitol is a spacious, light-filled haven in Evanston that strikes an…