Crema's Take
“Belmar Bakery is an Amarillo institution for custom cakes and pies that's been relied on for decades, but it's in real trouble right now—multiple recent reviews describe quality decline, missed orders, rude staff, and cakes that don't match what was ordered, with several long-time customers saying they're done after 15-30 years of loyalty. There's a single positive recent review suggesting the owner may be course-correcting, but the overwhelming pattern of disappointment means you should probably call ahead and ask hard questions before ordering anything important, or consider alternatives.”
What to expect
Classic coffee drinks done right. Quick-grab spot. Pastries and light food on the menu. Family friendly.
Google Reviews
See all on Google →It is update time. After my great disappointment in 2025 with the quality decline at Belmar Bakery, the owner took mine and others constructive criticism seriously. On the 24th of April 2026, I purchased 2 cherry pies, a cherry turnover and an iced Barvarian pretzel. My wife…
I have been a long time customer and have always ordered cakes and pies from Belmar. What happened to this place? I placed an order for my Thanksgiving pies over a week ago, went to pick them up the day before Thanksgiving at 4pm, I didn’t leave until around 7:30pm! There was a…
If there was an option for a zero star review, I’d leave it. This bakery has always been so reputable. I ordered a cake two days in advance for a birthday party and planned to pick up the cake right before the party. The cake hadn’t even been started when I arrived to pick it…
We have been ordering pies for 15 years. So disappointed in today’s service. Customer service today was at a 0 star rating for sure. The women working the counter were rude and didn’t acknowledge my mother when she requested her order that was a pre-order. Pick up time was at 12…
I want to share my experience respectfully, but honestly. We ordered a cake for my sweet aunt’s birthday party two full days in advance, and required us to pay over the phone. We arrived at the exact time we were told to pick it up, only to find out the cake wasn’t ready. The…
For our wedding we did a mix as top tier was lemon strawberry with cheesecake or buttercream icing, and lower tier was red velvet same icing. The cupcakes were mixed lemon strawberry and snkickerdoodle which blew me away. They delivered perfectly on time for our wedding and…
Crema Reviews
You might also like
Grandpa’s Donuts II
★ 4.7 (155)
This straightforward donut shop in Amarillo nails the basics with consistently…
Copilot Coffee
★ 4.6 (115)
Copilot Coffee is a warmly run neighborhood spot where the baristas genuinely…
Golden Waffle Company
★ 4.8 (1,582)
This beloved Amarillo spot has earned devoted fans with its perfectly executed…
Tea Time
★ 5.0 (102)
This elegant tea room transports you into a refined, intentionally curated…