Crema's Take
“Fellini's playful signature drinks like the Matchazz and Pistachio Paradise Latte are Instagram-worthy enough to justify the premium pricing, though the execution can be inconsistent and the tight bar seating means you'll need to time your visit carefully to snag a spot. The cozy Italian-style vibe and quality pastries make it worth a stop if you're in the Upper West Side and don't mind waiting, but go in with realistic expectations about speed and consistency rather than the TikTok hype.”
What to expect
Strong matcha and tea selection, with creative signature drinks. A slow-sit, outdoor seating spot, good for meetings. Full breakfast and pastries on the menu.
Google Reviews
See all on Google →We came across this cute coffee shop while we were in the area looking for a cozy spot to sit and warm us up. Although, it has a few 2-top tables it’s a very cute shop with a bar vibe and italian style. We ordered hot american coco which was good, hot italian coco which was…
Got a Matchazz with oat milk and sat down, very cosy and nice place. The drink was delicious and I’d get it again. The croissants looked nice but I couldn’t see any gluten free options. I went at 1:30pm on a Wednesday so it was quiet but I can imagine it gets busy at peak times…
Got pistachio paradise latte. Looked amazing, tasted decent. $11+ for one latte is a lot though. Took a while to make and the family waiting before us was also getting anxious waiting for their order as it was a morning on a school day. Definitely aesthetically pleasing -…
I had high hopes for this place, and I saw people bragging on TikTok about visiting this cafe. Upon arrival, I noticed that there were only four chairs available inside, all of which were occupied. So I decided to take out. The cashier had no personality, unfortunately; no hello…
This review is strictly based on takeout coffee and pastry. Ordered cappuccino, it tasted burnt—like how Starbucks used to burn their coffee. Croissant was a touch stale. The cover of this spot feels like a trendy well put together beautiful place to sip your coffee, but the…
Crema Reviews
You might also like
Duaa’s Cafe
★ 4.8 (201)
Duaa's is where you go for creative, Instagram-worthy drinks like strawberry…
Sipsteria UWS
★ 4.8 (253)
Sipsteria's signature sipspresso and French croissants are legitimately worth…
outro nyc
★ 4.4 (532)
Outro's taro coffee is a genuine revelation—people have been ordering the same…
Daniel's Coffee and More
★ 4.4 (150)
Daniel's serves some of New York's most talked-about specialty drinks—their…