Sugar Tree Cafe Nutley
358 Passaic Ave, Lyndhurst, NJ
Crema's Take
“Sugar Tree Cafe is a charming Nutley spot where attentive service and nostalgic 90s-inspired decor set the stage for generous pours of both traditional and creative specialty drinks. The kitchen shines brightest with indulgent breakfast creations like deep-fried cinnamon French toast and creative signature items, though their savory dishes can be hit-or-miss. It's the kind of place where staff members like Stella and Jamie become part of why regulars keep coming back—a cozy, chic neighborhood gathering spot that takes pride in freshly made everything.”
What to expect
Google Reviews
The service here is really good, our server was so nice. The decor is pretty and the drinks are a generous portion. Unfortunately the chicken and waffles were a miss, I didn’t enjoy them.
The food and drinks were very delicious! We had a delightful experience here. The atmosphere very chic and chill. Their service was outstanding. Stella served us in a very friendly and attentive manner. I Highly recommend this restaurant for brunch. The misery drink was an unexpected surprise, super hilarious and we didn’t even notice when the pic of my son was taken. Awesome place!
A Cozy atmosphere, five-star service, beautiful décor, and food/beverages that did not disappoint. Everything was freshly made and packed with flavor. We ordered the deep-fried cinnamon French toast, skirt steak and eggs, and the Passaic ave Breakfast, plus a hot chocolate and latte, so good! Huge thanks to Jack for taking great care of us (and helping with lighting for our photos!) and to Jaime for her patience and assistance at checkout. We will definitely be back!
If you have a chance to stop by this cute cafe in Nutley NJ. The decor , staff (especially Stella😉) and food is just a great place to chill. Some really great touches of the 90's. I got the smash burger slaps. Two patties cheese with a brioche bun. My lady got the notorious BLT. (Clever marketing) If you don't like any of these items come in for the coquito coffee and the nitro fries. Cajun spiced with a hint of sweetness. Crazy good. I honestly can't think of any real words right now. Great place with exceptional vibes.
I had the pleasure of being served by Jamie, and she was absolutely perfect. Her service was warm, attentive, and professional from start to finish. She checked in at the right moments, made great recommendations, and made sure everything was exactly how I wanted it. Her friendly personality and genuine care really made the experience stand out. Jamie is truly exceptional, and I’d love to be seated in her section again. Highly recommended! Please give her a raise ASAP
Crema Reviews
You might also like
The 3rd Wave Cafe
★ 4.4 (354)
Nestled in Lyndhurst, The 3rd Wave Cafe has earned genuine love from its…
El Coquí Café
★ 4.9 (272)
El Coquí Café brings genuine warmth to Lyndhurst with a tight-knit atmosphere…
Cupily Coffeehouse
★ 4.8 (198)
Cupily Coffeehouse is a warm, artsy neighborhood gem where the staff remembers…
Cubita Café
★ 4.6 (433)
Cubita Café is a warm Cuban gathering spot where the coffee is secondary to the…