57ninety Restaurant
5790 Transit Rd, Depew, NY
Crema's Take
“This Depew neighborhood gem serves up generous portions of Italian-American classics with the kind of care that keeps families coming back for years, from perfectly cooked shrimp scampi to crispy eggplant parmesan layered with fresh ricotta. The welcoming atmosphere and fair prices make it an ideal spot to linger over a meal with friends or family, where fresh bread arrives warm from the oven and the staff treats you like regulars. Whether you're grabbing takeout or settling in for a leisurely dinner, 57ninety delivers that homestyle Italian cooking experience without pretension.”
What to expect
Google Reviews
Great food, perfect portions. Had the shrimp scampi pasta was cooked perfect shrimp was not overcooked. Bread is fresh out of the oven with a delicious dipping oil. Side salad was crispy and fresh. Our waitress Jennifer was great made sure we had what we needed let us know about daily specials.
I take my dad and bro here all the time. We loved it when it was a different Italian joint, and it still delivers excellent American Italian cuisine at great prices, but with a much larger menu selection of food. Can’t go wrong with everything I’ve tried. I usually do the lasagna, it was delicious. Fresh bread and a huge tasty side salad to start.
Im partial, but this is only second to my mother in laws italian cooking(she'd kill me lol) food was fantastic friendly staff, HEALTHY portions fair prices. First place around I've seen with actual stuffed mushrooms, which were AMAZING. A meatball the size of your fist! Food was hot fresh and delicious. Only down side, it seemed a bit chilly inside we were at a bar top by the front window where we asked to sit, so maybe thats on us. Stuffed peppers, garlic bread with cheese baked spaghetti parm mmmmmm
I ordered take out and was very pleased with my order. I got an eggplant Parmesan dinner and a large cheese and pepperoni pizza. The eggplant dinner was crispy and had layers of ricotta in between. The pizza was cooked to perfection! Highly recommend ordering take out or dinning in.
I recently visited 57 Ninety Restaurant, a spot we frequented previously but had also been curious about, since they opened and took over the space that was formerly La Costa Verde. Since they're celebrating their first anniversary, it felt like the perfect time to give them a try. On this visit I went specifically for their Tuesday Pizza special and was happy I did. The pizza was so tasty, I'll absolutely get it again. The menu has a lot of variety, so I'm already looking forward to my next visit to try some of their other dishes, perhaps for a sit-down meal. One thing I love is that they offer two different sauces: a sweet one reminiscent of the previous restaurant's sauce, and a more seasoned option. The staff was wonderful, delightful and incredibly helpful. They made placing my order a seamless and efficient process. Inside, the restaurant has a much more modern and comfortable feel than before. Everything was very clean and organized, though I did notice a persistent, slightly off smell that was also present with the previous owners (so it may be building related). For a local, non-chain meal, 57 Ninety is certainly worth checking out!