Seymours Cafe
Seymours Cafe — photo 2
Seymours Cafe — photo 3
Seymours Cafe — photo 4
Seymours Cafe — photo 5

Seymours Cafe

567 S Livingston Ave, West Orange, NJ

★★★★★4.5(628 Google reviews)

Crema's Take

Seymour's Cafe is a West Orange gem that excels at both leisurely brunch experiences and quick coffee runs, with genuinely impressive execution across everything from their Salmon Benedict to fresh-baked pastries and thoughtfully crafted specialty drinks. What sets them apart is the care that radiates through every interaction—attentive staff who'll have you sample the French Onion soup and a kitchen that treats each plate like it matters, earning them a stellar 4.5-star reputation among nearly 630 reviewers. Whether you're settling in for a slow morning or grabbing a quality coffee between errands, this is the kind of place where consistency and warmth make regular customers feel genuinely welcomed.

What to expect

MeetingsPastriesLight foodSlow sitSpecialty drinksQuick grabTraditional drinksFull breakfast

Google Reviews

Brian M
★★★★★2 months ago

I had to come to Seymour’s Cafe as I was out at the Mall in Short and they are less than 10 minute’s away. This is a unique 5 star restaurant that is worthy of a visit by Guy Fieri if he is still doing road trips for “Diners , Drive Ins and Dives”. All I can say is you have to try them. It’s worth the drive! They put a different spin on everything they serve. When you walk in, you may think it’s a local deli that you go for a take out breakfast or lunch. Then you see the tables and all the customers sitting there. They have everything you could want from coffee, teas, juices, smoothies, sandwiches paninis, poke bowls, pancakes, waffles, breakfast and lunch dishes. You can tell that they have a ton of regular customers, that are very loyal. They also do catering, and even though I live in Brooklyn, they are willing to deliver to me. Today I met some amazing people at the restaurant. Congratulations to Carlos who is a new manager. He is a US Army Veteran who saw combat action and I hope everyone will thank him for his service when they visit. Carlos really cares about his customers. When we entered we were greeted, he started up a conversation and checked in on us throughout our meal. Victor was our server and he made great recommendations. He was also very friendly, we also met Melvin who was a runner and made sure the food came out promptly with all the accoutrements. Today we started with the blueberry pancakes. You get two large pancakes that are as big as the dish. They had blueberries inside and outside, whipped cream and maple syrup. Probably the best I’ve ever had! I had the apple, lemon, ginger juice which hit the spot. We also had the tuna poke bowl and the shrimp fajita bowl. The ingredients and fish were fresh and plentiful. I was stuffed by the time we left. I would highly recommend Seymour’s Cafe if you want to experience phenomenal food and customer service.

Holly Kerin
★★★★★4 months ago

Worth all the dollars you’ll spend here, and it will be a lot, but I’ve not ordered 1 thing here that I’ve been disappointed in. All stuff is super tasty & so fresh. Salmon Benedict is my favorite

Jose Ferreira
★★★★★4 months ago

Always come to Seymour’s when I’m town. Food is very tasty and nicely plated. Staff is attentive and super friendly. Their staff had us sample their French Onion soup, which was delicious and comforting on a cold snowy day. Always order either their panani sandwiches or classic Benedict with home fries-highly recommended!

Katie Guiles
★★★★★6 months ago

I got an everything bagel with egg and cheese. And there everything bagel is pretty much a plain bagel. There is nothing on top. And you have to ask for extra bacon because it’s here is only egg and cheese pretty much inside. Very disappointing

Marcos Lucilla
★★★★★a year ago

Really good place. They have good deli, a diversity of products and a really nice atmosphere. If you near for a breakfast and a lunch, worth it. It’s a welcome place, but they really care of you. Congrats.

Crema Reviews

No Crema reviews yet

Been here? Be the first to leave a review in the app.

Write a review on iOS