Yardsale cafe
620 5th Ave #2, Brooklyn, NY
Crema's Take
“Yardsale Cafe is a Park Slope gem that feels like wandering through a nostalgic yard sale, with walls lined with quirky memorabilia and vintage treasures that are actually for sale, creating an unpretentious and wonderfully laid-back atmosphere. The real draw here is their exceptional bakery program—reviewers are genuinely obsessed with the babka and pastries, with folks making special trips just for these treats—paired with solid, traditional coffee and a genuinely sweet staff that makes the cozy space feel like a neighborhood living room. It's the kind of place where you linger over a perfectly heated cookie and good conversation, whether you're catching up with friends or settling in after a morning run.”
What to expect
Classic coffee drinks done right. A slow-sit spot, good for meetings. Pastries and light food on the menu.
Google Reviews
Best babka I’ve ever had, ohhhh my goodness. Best bakery I’ve been to in a long time, and I am bakery-obsessed. Already dreaming of how and when I can make my way back to Park Slope just for this and the super chocolate-chip cookie. But that babka, this subtle mix of Nutella and…
got the babka and it hit perfectly after 10 miles into my long run. cute, laid-back space with solid coffee. small but cozy, and staff were super sweet. would return to try the sandwiches and more pastries. a nice break from the busier cafés nearby.
After reading Google reviews with high ratings, I left home early and stopped by before going to work. It was around 7:30 shortly after the store opened, and I was impressed that all the products were lined up in the showcase. The calm and pleasant staff made a wonderful start…
CASUAL CAFE WITH INCREDIBLE FOOD 🥮 Yardsale Cafe feels exactly like how it sounds when you step inside. Unpretentious vibe made up of literal yard sale memorabilia on the walls that are for sale. The owner takes pride in what he bakes. The babka is well-known and delicious. So…
Definitely makes you feel like you're at a Yard sale back in the early 2000's when you walk in. Selling anywhere between hats, T-shirts, happy meal toys & collection cards. The cookie has to be heated when eaten. Nutella Babka is very chocolatey and moist. Only has one table by…
Crema Reviews
You might also like
Drip & Blend
★ 5.0 (172)
The upstairs seating area at Drip & Blend has become the neighborhood's most…
Blue Brown Cafe
★ 4.9 (305)
Blue Brown's Thai-inflected coffee drinks—think Dirty Thai Tea Lattes and iced…
11:11 Cafe
★ 4.9 (301)
11:11 Cafe's lavender matcha latte and creative specialty drinks are the kind…
Postmark Cafe
★ 4.8 (310)
Postmark's drip coffee is genuinely some of the best in Brooklyn—clean,…