Crema's Take
“This pie shop lives up to its name with standout fruit pies—cherry and strawberry rhubarb get particular praise—though their savory options like chicken and broccoli pie prove they're serious about more than just dessert. The vibe is genuinely warm and family-friendly, with staff who seem to actually care about your visit, though you should know whole pies command premium prices that don't always justify the quality. If you're in Lake Geneva with a sweet tooth and patience for a leisurely sit, it's worth the stop; just manage expectations on value.”
What to expect
Classic coffee drinks done right. A slow-sit spot, good for meetings. Pastries and light food on the menu. Family friendly.
Google Reviews
See all on Google →This is fabulous! Why aren't there any pie restaurants in Florida? I had chicken and broccoli pie, quiche, and apple pie. All great.
My wife and I stopped in before Christmas for a Pecan pie. We were very underwhelmed by the pie and the hefty price tag of $34. We did not feel the pie had good flavor and thought it didn't taste very homemade. The nice woman than helped us was fantastic, however.
Visited today for the first time. Had a slice of cherry pie and strawberry rhubarb crunch. DELISH! Both of them! Employees were very friendly and very helpful with all our questions. Got a Lake Berry to bring home and a frozen take and bake peach to bring home! Pie crust is…
This one is a gem. I am at least once a month in lake geneva for work and when I am here I always come here. They have a good variety of sweets, but the cherry pie is top notch. If you have a sweet tooth as I do, I would definitely recommend to try this place
Oh my goodness; the Cherry Crumb pie! Absolutely delicious! I tried my friends' apple crumble pie & that also was incredible. We tried the peanut butter cookies & they were so soft. Incredible place. It is SO cute inside. It has tiny tick tac toe game at the tables. Adorable.…
Crema Reviews
You might also like
Cafezinho at Main Street Cafe
★ 4.7 (285)
Their signature Canelinha—a cinnamon-forward Brazilian-inspired drink—has…
The Latte Cafe & Bakery
★ 4.6 (521)
The Latte Cafe & Bakery nails the cozy small-town coffee shop fantasy with…
Harry's Cafe & Place
★ 3.8 (204)
Harry's is a genuinely beloved family-run diner that's been in Lake Geneva…
Inspired
★ 4.8 (544)
The staff here genuinely treats every order like it matters—locals consistently…