Crema's Take
“This charming bakery-coffee hybrid is worth the drive for genuinely excellent pastries—think buttery cinnamon rolls and peach coffee cake made in-house—paired with thoughtfully crafted specialty drinks that go beyond the usual suspects. The space feels like a friend's kitchen, warm and welcoming enough to settle in for hours, making it equally perfect for solo work sessions or meeting up with family over breakfast. If you're anywhere near Jerome, the combination of real baked goods, creative brunch items, and unpretentious hospitality makes this a serious destination.”
What to expect
Specialty coffee. A slow-sit spot, good for meetings. Full breakfast and pastries on the menu. Family friendly.
Google Reviews
See all on Google →I needed a place to hang out for the day while my sons were at a day camp at Clayville; Bayleaf & Butterscotch was the perfect place! The food and coffee were delicious, the service and ambiance warm and welcoming. Every town, big or small needs a cafe like this!
If you’re in the Pleasant Plains area and you haven’t yet visited Bayleaf & Butterscotch, you are seriously missing out. This charming bakery, coffee shop, and brunch spot is run by one of the sweetest people you’ll meet—and it’s not just the atmosphere that’s warm, but the food…
We drove out of our way to pick up bakery items, (cinnamon rolls, banana bread, and peach pastries) for our Bed & Breakfast guests. It was well worth the trip. They loved everything! The cinnamon rolls were outstanding, my personal favorite! We also enjoyed a pastry while at…
Cute space with delicious, REAL baked goods! Real pastries! My peach coffee cake was amazing! (Lotus drinks can be made without caffeine!) Ordered a custom cake, too! We have plans to come back often! Excited to support a local bakery! Every foodie should head this way!
Wow, what an incredible experience - the pastries were very fresh and the drinks were delicious! We had the pizza, strawberry poptart and the ham and Gouda cheese poptart - which we ended up ordering more of - such a great stop in Pleasant Plains! (:
Crema Reviews
You might also like
Hazel's Cafe
★ 4.7 (228)
Hazel's pulls off the rare trick of being both a serious espresso destination…
The Miner’s Café
★ 4.6 (584)
The Miner's Café wins you over the moment you step inside—the aroma alone will…
The Local Motive
★ 4.9 (302)
The Local Motive is a rare coffee shop that takes its food as seriously as its…
Ten Drops Coffee
★ 4.8 (510)
The owner's roasting expertise here is genuinely exceptional—regulars swear by…