Crema's Take
“Oak Mill Bakery has a real reputation for custom cakes and pastries—people genuinely love their desserts when the order goes right—but the 3.9 rating reflects a troubling pattern of mix-ups on custom orders, including customers receiving entirely wrong cakes for important occasions. If you're ordering off-menu or for a special event, read recent reviews carefully and confirm details multiple times; their pastry case and standard items seem safer bets. It's a solid neighborhood bakery for walk-in pastries and coffee, but not reliable enough for high-stakes custom orders.”
What to expect
Classic coffee drinks done right. A slow-sit spot, good for meetings. Full breakfast, pastries, and light food on the menu. Family friendly. Parking available.
Google Reviews
See all on Google →Oak Mill Bakery is a fantastic choice for anyone looking for delicious cakes and pastries. I have ordered birthday cakes from them multiple times, and I can confidently say that they are the best I have ever tasted. Each cake is not only delicious but also beautifully designed,…
Terrible location, I ordered in advance the birthday cake for my 10 year old daughter and was supposed to be a nuttela cake, when we picked up the cake WAS A TOTALLY DIFFERENT CAKE!!!! in and out was completely different than promised and the nuttela was nowhere to be found…
Love this bakery! Have been a client for years. And staff is so friendly. The new Ukrainian girl is sooo sweet and friendly! Made my day today! Merry Christmas and thank you for best desserts!
I placed an order for a standard raspberry whipped cream cake ( off their menu) a week before a birthday. I was very excited since Ive had many delicious cakes from their other location in Niles. However, this cake was disappointing. The bottom cake layer was dense and dry, the…
This is an awesome bakery 🧁. I happen to eat a cake at workplace brought by a colleague for an occasion. Had a chance to only get a small piece ☹️. It was so delicious and wanting more. I had to go checkout if it stands up to the same first impression. So, here I am with a…
Crema Reviews
You might also like
Egg Harbor Cafe
★ 4.5 (985)
Egg Harbor Cafe is a breakfast destination that does the fundamentals…
Andy's Cafe
★ 4.4 (959)
Andy's Cafe is built around an obsession with chilaquiles and al pastor…
Blu Fig Cafe
★ 4.9 (370)
Blu Fig's creamy, robust lattes and carefully curated pastries—especially their…
Gerry's Cafe
★ 4.9 (308)
Gerry's Cafe is a nonprofit coffee shop that intentionally hires people with…