The Islander Cafe
52 Main St, New Castle Island, NH
Crema's Take
“Nestled on scenic New Castle Island, this beloved neighborhood spot excels at the fundamentals—expertly crafted traditional coffee drinks paired with made-to-order breakfast sandwiches, quiches, and cinnamon rolls that keep locals coming back. The intimate, cozy dining space feels like a well-kept secret worth seeking out, where genuine hospitality and consistently excellent food have earned it a devoted following of families and friends looking for a genuine, unhurried coffee experience.”
What to expect
Google Reviews
So yummy, highly recommend the Quiche and the eggy cinnamon roll! Sandwich also clutched
Amazing. Period. 11/10. Just left and want to go back for my first time again. Will forever be impressed by places that do the simple things extremely well. ❤️ S/o Amy for showing love and giving all the good vibes ✌🏾
This place is a hidden gem it’s adorable on the inside and they just have an amazing space they are working with, not to mention the food is absolutely amazing their sandwiches are so so so delicious! Especially their coffee as well they have excellent coffee, the vibe of the inside is so so good they are pretty small inside however they have a good amount of seating for everyone to be able to sit and enjoy the morning! The people there were also excellent so nice and friendly and it was so nice to just talk and have a great morning :) would definitely recommend this place to anyone thinking about coming here!!!
What a Hidden Gem! Tucked away off the beaten path, this place is truly worth the detour. The drive there offers stunning views, setting the tone for a great experience. There was a bit of a line, but it moved quickly, and we even scored a table despite limited seating. Everything exceeded expectations: the bagel was fresh and perfectly chewy, the donut had me drooling, and the coffee was incredibly smooth and flavorful. A must-visit!
Amazing. Do NOT miss it. Delicious breakfast sandwiches, salad, coffee, donuts and cookies. Sandwiches and salads are made fresh to order. Not too many tables for dining in but so cute cozy and coastal. Staff was polite and prompt - great customer focused attitude. Will definitely return.