Yoders Pie Craft Coffee
Yoders Pie Craft Coffee — photo 2
Yoders Pie Craft Coffee — photo 3
Yoders Pie Craft Coffee — photo 4
Yoders Pie Craft Coffee — photo 5

Yoders Pie Craft Coffee

3404 Bahia Vista St, Sarasota, FL

★★★★★4.9(73 Google reviews)

Crema's Take

Tucked next to Yoder's beloved pie shop, this converted-truck café serves inventive seasonal drinks like Apple Chai and Pumpkin Cheesecake Lattes alongside freshly baked mini pies that feel indulgent without overwhelming. The covered outdoor seating creates an inviting spot to linger with neighbors or visiting friends, where thoughtful baristas customize every cup and pair it perfectly with house-made pastries and pie.

What to expect

Signature drinksFamily friendlySpecialty drinksMatcha & teaPastriesTraditional drinksOutdoor seatingMeetingsSlow sit

Google Reviews

Shannon Heitner
★★★★★3 months ago

We were visiting from MN and looking for a good local coffee shop to try and so we stopped at Yoder's. Best decision ever. The coffee is fantastic and they have so many customizing options. Also the pricing is SO reasonable for the size coffee you get. I was shocked at how cheap it was for how good quality it is. I would highly recommend stopping by.

Gayle Mercado
★★★★★5 months ago

Delicious coffee and matcha! We stopped here after ordering some food from the restaurant. Great place to relax and enjoy a drink and pie. They have a covered seating area that is perfect to sit and relax. The drink specials : Nutella coffee drink and matcha were delicious!! The girls working there were so sweet. Especially appreciated the sweet message on every cup lid. The atmosphere is truly welcoming and relaxing, a great place to enjoy a delicious drink and a dessert. Will definitely be coming back!

Natalie Santana
★★★★★5 months ago

So beyond good! We came by to pick up some pies for Thanksgiving and we were pleasantly surprised to find a Yoder’s coffee shop Nextdoor. The coffee was delicious and even included a beautiful message on top. Will be returning every time we are in town.

ZieGee Official
★★★★★6 months ago

We visited this place for the first time! They offer so many delicious coffees and cakes that we couldn't easily pick just one. We tried the Apple Chai, the Pumpkin Cheesecake Latte, and a Hazelnut Latte. We also had little pies. They also have little games on the tables! Fun! Everything was so delicious. It's a cozy little spot with super friendly and kind service! 100% recommend! Go visit them; you'll love it! :) -ZieGee-

Valeriya Rozin
★★★★★6 months ago

Yoder’s Pie Craft Coffee Co. is cozy, with a lovely seating area. It’s a truck converted into a café. They bake fresh mini personal pies — small enough to finish by yourself, but big enough to feel satisfied. The key lime is particularly good. The drink assortment spans coffee, tea, and non-caffeine options. I tried their cold apple cider — I’ve never tasted a tastier apple cider. The presentation is beautiful, especially if you’re looking for Insta-perfect pictures. If you feel like you need something more in your tummy before grabbing a coffee, you can purchase tasty sandwiches next door and enjoy your drink & pie afterward. Perfect place to meet with friends or have a first date. Definitely recommend.

Crema Reviews

No Crema reviews yet

Been here? Be the first to leave a review in the app.

Write a review on iOS