Legacy Supreme Coffee
1237 Bay Rd, Webster, NY
Crema's Take
“This charming Webster village gem combines artisanal pastries handmade by the owner with thoughtfully crafted coffee and creative drinks like their standout strawberry matcha—all served in an impeccably detailed space adorned with fresh flowers and a warm, family-friendly atmosphere. Every element, from the organic ingredients to the flawless attention to detail in both the baked goods and service, reflects genuine care for creating a memorable, slowpaced experience worth returning to.”
What to expect
Google Reviews
Lovely and quaint bakery. We stopped by this morning and got a variety of pastries and drinks. The strawberry matcha was unique and absolutely amazing. Cinnamon latte was sweet but tasty. Scones were light, fluffy with a delicious tartness and the brownie was rich and full of chocolate. Very very reasonably priced for the quality of food/drinks. Will definitely be back again!
Very cute coffee bar located in the village of Webster. A variety of wonderful baked goods, grilled sandwiches and excellent coffee made to order. Freshly cut roses on the table today was a wonderful touch. I highly recommend this place! Tell em Dave sent ya!
Everything here is absolutely organic! The pastries are incredibly delicious — handmade by the owner with so much love. The coffee is amazing, honestly the best I’ve ever had. I’ll definitely be coming back!😍
A charming bakery that’s absolutely pristine. Their attention to detail is undeniably flawless. From the fresh flowers on each table to the cutlery, selection of baked goods to the customer service. The lovely Victoria was eager and dedicated to answer all of our questions with a smile. We initially ordered a Hot Tiramisu Latte, Coffee and 2 Cinnamon Buns. The drinks were delicious. But those Cinnamon Buns…..WoW and WoW again. I can’t remember the last time I had a bun so delicious that’s fresh out of the oven and the icing wasn’t sickly sweet. The reviewers were right again! Then my partner decided to induce a self inflicted food coma by ordering Pompushko & an Almond Flourless Cake! For once it was difficult to get him out of the bakery! My greed finally gave way and I too decided to jump on the bandwagon and got myself a Napoleon Cake that was delicately flavoured and yummy. Sweet Square Bakery without a doubt deserves those 5 ⭐ ratings. If you are reading this then please don’t bypass this place. You won’t be disappointed. Please have some menus so we can eat our way through it! We can’t wait to go back and munch through the rest of the menu!
4/2/25: It opened last week. I bought a chocolate 🍫 chip cookie 🍪, a scone, & a chocolate 🍫 brownie. The place was charming & a great new place for people to enjoy our wonderful village atmosphere. The chocolate 🍫 chip cookie 🍪 was warm & tasted like my mother's from back in the day: heavenly. All my treats were warm, freshly baked from scratch 😋, & flavorful. 4/25/25: Their warm cinnamon bun was very tasty ❕️ I bought pastries. They were still soft & flavorful the next day. Very good quality.