Bagel Boutique
Bagel Boutique — photo 2
Bagel Boutique — photo 3
Bagel Boutique — photo 4
Bagel Boutique — photo 5

Bagel Boutique

6581 Carlisle Pike, Mechanicsburg, PA

★★★★4.3(367 Google reviews)

Crema's Take

Bagel Boutique is a charming neighborhood spot that takes its bagels seriously, baking them fresh daily and serving creative sandwiches like the Lox of Love and Porky Pig that keep regulars coming back from across town. The unapologetically pink, NYC-inspired atmosphere makes it the kind of place where you actually want to linger over your cold brew and chat with friends, and their solid coffee program complements the food-focused menu beautifully. It's the rare bagel shop that feels equally welcoming to families grabbing a quick bite and coffee lovers settling in for an unhurried morning.

What to expect

Slow sitFamily friendlyLight foodPastriesMeetingsTraditional drinks

Google Reviews

Jessica Bolles
★★★★4 months ago

Absolutely delicious & tons of variety! Bagel sandwiches are so good; tried the Porky Pig sandwich on an everything bagel & the Philly burrito! Also grabbed a cold brew and a lemonade while we there. Only reason for a 4 star is the wait time. Love to see the community supporting a local business but do expect to wait for your food. The ordering kiosks did help with the line but it did take about 35 minutes before food came out. Packed parking lot, but we did manage to find a space. Worth returning to!

Kevin Boller
★★★★★5 months ago

Excellent bagels, baked fresh.. My wife bit into her lox of love, and immediately commented that this is a five. The decor is extremely pink, so it helps if you love pink.

Donald Boller
★★★★6 months ago

Food: superb! Atmosphere: very nice! Tidy and clean too. (That sign in the bathroom: funny 😂) I was just a little surprised how long my small order took to prepare. But the NYC vibe: LOVE IT!

Dominic Bornman
★★★★★6 months ago

This is a very neat little place, conveniently located with a variety of items for many different desires. We were a party of three who all got bagel sandwiches. One of the sandwiches was with a gluten free bagel which is a huge plus for anyone with a gluten free diet. We went around 7:45am on Sunday morning and there was only one person in front of us in line but I imagine it would get a lot more crowded later in the morning. The food was very good. It was served in an adequate amount of time (not too slow like we wonder what they are doing back there but not too fast like its fast food). Each bagel was individually wrapped, cut in half and placed in a to-go plastic container. Their pastries also looked really good and carefully made. I wouldve tried one but it was pretty early for a sweet. Their bagel selection is vast and I wanted to try every single one. Definitely would go back and recommend to others in the area

J T
★★★★★11 months ago

Came here a few weeks ago for a bagel heard about it even though I live on the opposite side of town we decide to go and check it out. This place is so cute. I’m a little more adventurous. She’s a little more traditional. She got the bag and cream cheese I got there very well garlic, and Butter stuffed bagel, which was mine blowing literally one of the best bagels. I think I’ve ever had and this thing is big probably could’ve split it or at least I eat 3/4 and she ate a quarter but the ambience the staff just the whole thing I got going on here is just really cool cute and original. I don’t know if this is a chain, I didn’t look it up. I think it’s a standalone. I definitely would come back here. I don’t have Little’s but if you have little kids, they have a bunch of little sugary flavored type bagels you know with different toppings and stuff that would satisfying even the pickiest of appetite. I just hope this place makes it it did seem like it was doing pretty well while we were there a lot of people coming and going and they do looks like a good bit of pick up to go order. I know over the years has been places in this spot that I’ve come and gone, but I really do hope this place stands the test of time. I will definitely be back.

Crema Reviews

No Crema reviews yet

Been here? Be the first to leave a review in the app.

Write a review on iOS