Crema's Take
“The peanut butter cold brew here is genuinely exceptional enough that people drive 40 minutes out of their way for it, and reviews consistently rave about it as their signature drink—if you're skeptical about flavored coffee, this is the one to try. Beyond that, they're a solid all-around spot with a welcoming vibe, quality espresso drinks, and the kind of cozy atmosphere that makes families and regulars want to linger. It's worth the trip if you're in the area, especially if you have any curiosity about what makes their peanut butter cold brew worth the hype.”
What to expect
Cold brew standout, with creative signature drinks. A slow-sit spot, outdoor seating. Full breakfast, pastries, and light food on the menu. Family friendly. Parking available.
Google Reviews
See all on Google →UPDATE: Angie reached out and very generously gave us a gift card. When going back the drinks were made perfectly delicious! And it looks as though they've updated the prices on their menu. The manager Damian was also extremely friendly and made great recommendations! Overall,…
Cozy little coffee shop. We first were introduced to their peanut butter cold brew when they were selling drinks at our eldest kiddo’s soccer game next door at the school. We’d never heard of that being done (the drink type) and had to try it and it was delicious! Fast forward a…
If there is one thing you do in Sun Prairie, let it be going here! Their peanut butter cold brew is truly life changing and is worth a drive! My sister and I went inside to grab a drink (she’s very particular about her coffee!) and by the time we got to the car she’d asked if we…
This place is a fantastic coffee and all around drink shop. They have both flavored sodas and coffee beverages you can order along with food items. Might I suggest the peanut butter cold brew with extra peanut butter and butterscotch added in. Get the biggest size possible…
I absolutely love this place. I’m so jealous of those that live close! Wish it was around when I was living on the east side of Madison😩 BUT that still doesn’t stop me from taking the 40 minute drive!!! The peanut butter cold brew is insane. I’m not your die hard coffee lover,…
Crema Reviews
You might also like
Ancora Cafe + Bakery
★ 4.6 (629)
Ancora pulls off the rare feat of being a genuinely comfortable neighborhood…
Firefly Coffeehouse
★ 4.8 (881)
Firefly has built a genuine community around Cinnamon Roll Fridays—a weekly…
Monona Bakery and Eatery
★ 4.5 (835)
This spot does old-school diner comfort food really well—think enchiladas…
Luke's Cafe
★ 4.6 (672)
Luke's Cafe pulls off the rare feat of handling massive groups without losing…